C2 British · Dialogue 20
After the Audition
A violin teacher gives a sixteen-year-old honest feedback after he is not chosen for a national youth orchestra, and they make a plan for next year.
29 lines · Tap a line to hear it again
Dialogue
Ms Ingrid Dahl:Come in, Sam. Put your case down. I heard the news from your mum this morning. I'm really sorry.
Sam:Yeah. Well. Kofi got in, so at least somebody from this school did.
Ms Ingrid Dahl:That's generous of you. Have you read the feedback the panel sent?
Sam:I've read it about fifteen times. 'Beautiful tone, secure intonation, a tendency to rush in faster passages.' Which is basically saying no, nicely.
Ms Ingrid Dahl:May I see? Hmm. Actually, Sam, I'd read that very differently. Two of those three comments are exactly what panels hope to hear. And the third is something we can fix.
Sam:If it's that easy to fix, why didn't I get in?
Ms Ingrid Dahl:I didn't say easy. I said fixable. Can I be honest with you? Even if it's not what you want to hear today?
Sam:Go on, then.
Ms Ingrid Dahl:They're right. In the fast section of the Mendelssohn, the bit just before the return of the main theme, you pull ahead of the beat. I've noticed it in lessons since September. When you're nervous, it gets worse.
Sam:But everyone's nervous in an audition. And the pianist was quite slow, to be fair. I had to sort of drag her along.
Ms Ingrid Dahl:I was in the room next door, remember. I could hear through the wall. She wasn't slow. You were early. It's a very common habit in talented players, by the way. Your fingers know the notes so well that they want to get there first.
Sam:So it's my fault, basically.
Ms Ingrid Dahl:It's not about fault. It's about a habit, and habits can be changed. If I thought you'd reached your limit, I'd tell you, kindly. I don't think that. I think you were close.
Sam:How close?
Ms Ingrid Dahl:They had a hundred and forty violinists for twelve places. Your feedback is better than most. Close.
Sam:I don't know, though. Part of me thinks I should just give up on it. Kofi's been playing since he was four. I only started at nine.
Ms Ingrid Dahl:Sam, I was turned down by the youth orchestra in Norway twice when I was your age. The second time, I cried on the train all the way back to Bergen. I got in on my third try. Rejection isn't a verdict on whether you belong in music. It's information.
Sam:Twice? Really? You never said.
Ms Ingrid Dahl:You never failed an audition before. Now, the next one is in eleven months. That's plenty of time, if we're methodical. Shall I tell you what I'd suggest?
Sam:Okay. Yeah.
Ms Ingrid Dahl:First, the metronome, every day, for that passage. Start at eighty, well below the real speed, and only move it up by four each week when it's completely steady. By March, you should reach a hundred and twenty without trying.
Sam:That sounds painfully slow.
Ms Ingrid Dahl:It is. That's rather the point. Second, record yourself every Friday and listen back the next day, with fresh ears. You'll hear the rushing far more clearly than when you're playing. And third, you need to perform in front of people regularly, so that nerves become routine. The lunchtime concerts here are once a month. I'd like you in every one.
Sam:Every one? In front of the whole school?
Ms Ingrid Dahl:In front of about thirty people eating sandwiches. They're the kindest audience in Manchester. Then, in June, we'll do a mock audition with two teachers you don't know, so it feels real.
Sam:Okay. That's actually a proper plan. I think I just needed a day to sulk first.
Ms Ingrid Dahl:You're entitled to a day. Possibly two. But no more than that, because the metronome doesn't care about our feelings.
Sam:Fine. Eighty, on Monday. And I'll tell Kofi congratulations properly. I sort of mumbled it at him yesterday.
Ms Ingrid Dahl:Good man. That matters too. Now, play me the opening, slowly. Let's see that beautiful tone they mentioned.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| panel/ˈpænl/ | a small group of people chosen to judge or decide something |
| intonation/ˌɪntəˈneɪʃn/ | in music, how exactly a player hits the right notes, not too high or too low |
| verdict/ˈvɜːdɪkt/ | a final judgement or decision about something |
| methodical/məˈθɒdɪkl/ | doing things carefully, step by step, in a fixed order |
| metronome/ˈmetrənəʊm/ | a device that makes a regular clicking sound to help musicians keep the beat |
| routine/ruːˈtiːn/ | normal and usual, not special or frightening any more |
| mock/mɒk/ | done as practice, to copy a real test or event |
| sulk/sʌlk/ | to stay quiet and in a bad mood because you are disappointed |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.