C2 British · Dialogue 10
A Puzzling Case
A junior doctor presents a patient with tiredness and joint pain, and a senior consultant teaches him to look again before ordering more tests.
26 lines · Tap a line to hear it again
Dialogue
Dr Margaret Shaw:Come in, Tom. You wanted to talk about the lady in bay four?
Dr Tom Adeyemi:Yes. Mrs Harding, forty-two, a primary school teacher. She's had three months of tiredness and pain in her hands and knees. Her inflammatory marker is mildly raised, and the pain's in both hands, symmetrical, and worse in the mornings. I think it's rheumatoid arthritis. I'd like to request an MRI of her hands and refer her to the rheumatology team.
Dr Margaret Shaw:Possibly. But before we spend six hundred pounds on a scan, talk me through how you got there.
Dr Tom Adeyemi:Well, it's symmetrical joint pain, morning stiffness and a raised marker. It's almost textbook.
Dr Margaret Shaw:How long does the stiffness last in the mornings?
Dr Tom Adeyemi:She said about ten minutes.
Dr Margaret Shaw:Ten minutes. In rheumatoid arthritis you'd usually expect an hour or more. Which joints in her hands, exactly?
Dr Tom Adeyemi:The second and third knuckles, on both sides.
Dr Margaret Shaw:Interesting. Have you looked at page two of her blood results?
Dr Tom Adeyemi:I… skimmed it, to be honest. The blood count was normal.
Dr Margaret Shaw:Have a look at the ferritin.
Dr Tom Adeyemi:Oh. One thousand one hundred. That's very high. I'm afraid I assumed it was up because of the inflammation.
Dr Margaret Shaw:It can be, but not usually to that degree when the inflammatory marker is only mildly raised. Iron overload, haemochromatosis, typically causes tiredness and pain in exactly those two knuckles. It's one of those conditions that hides in plain sight, because each symptom on its own is so ordinary.
Dr Tom Adeyemi:I hadn't thought of that at all. I feel a bit foolish.
Dr Margaret Shaw:Don't. Everybody anchors on the first diagnosis that fits. The skill is noticing that you've done it. So here's a habit I'd like you to get into: before you order anything, write down three possibilities, and for each one ask what you'd expect to find if it were true, and what would argue against it. Go on, give me three.
Dr Tom Adeyemi:Rheumatoid arthritis, haemochromatosis, and maybe something viral?
Dr Margaret Shaw:Why viral?
Dr Tom Adeyemi:Because she's a teacher. She mentioned there'd been a rash going round her class just before this started. Children with bright red cheeks.
Dr Margaret Shaw:Slapped cheek. That virus can cause joint pain in adults for weeks. Well remembered. Patients very often tell us the answer; we just have to be listening. So what tests do you actually need now?
Dr Tom Adeyemi:An iron study and a gene test for haemochromatosis, an antibody test for the virus, and the usual rheumatoid blood tests. They're all blood tests. The MRI can wait.
Dr Margaret Shaw:Good. That's cheaper, quicker and kinder to the patient. And if the iron studies come back high?
Dr Tom Adeyemi:Then she'd probably have blood taken regularly to bring the iron down, and we'd check her liver.
Dr Margaret Shaw:Exactly. Write it up, and come and find me when the results are back, probably on Thursday. Oh, and Tom? Admitting that you'd skimmed page two was the most useful thing you said today.
Dr Tom Adeyemi:Thanks. I'll be reading every page from now on.
Dr Margaret Shaw:Good. And go and tell Mrs Harding what we're doing and why. Patients cope far better with uncertainty when somebody bothers to explain it.
Dr Tom Adeyemi:I will. I'll go and see her now.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| symmetrical/sɪˈmetrɪkl/ | the same on both sides |
| refer/rɪˈfɜː/ | to send a patient to a specialist doctor |
| stiffness/ˈstɪfnəs/ | a feeling that your joints are hard to move |
| textbook/ˈtekstbʊk/ | a perfect, typical example of something, just as described in books |
| skimmed/skɪmd/ | read very quickly, without looking at the details |
| ferritin/ˈferɪtɪn/ | a substance in the blood that shows how much iron the body is storing |
| Iron overload/ˌaɪən ˈəʊvələʊd/ | a condition in which the body keeps far too much of a metal it needs only in small amounts |
| in plain sight/ɪn ˌpleɪn ˈsaɪt/ | where anyone could see it, but people still fail to notice |
| anchors/ˈæŋkəz/ | fixes their thinking on one idea and does not move away from it |
| Slapped cheek/ˌslæpt ˈtʃiːk/ | a common virus in children that makes their cheeks bright red |
| antibody/ˈæntibɒdi/ | a substance the body makes to fight a particular illness |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.