C1 British · Dialogue 23
Feedback After the Audition
Lucy's violin teacher explains why she wasn't chosen for the national youth orchestra, and together they make a plan for her next try.
25 lines · Tap a line to hear it again
Dialogue
Mr Haddad:Come in, Lucy. Sit down. I've had the panel's notes back, and I wanted to go through them with you in person rather than by email.
Lucy:I already know I didn't get in. The letter came on Friday. You don't have to be nice about it.
Mr Haddad:I'm not going to be nice. I'm going to be honest, which is more useful. And honestly, a lot of it is very good.
Lucy:But not good enough.
Mr Haddad:Not this year. Just so you know, there were a hundred and forty violinists going for twelve places. Most of them were a year or two older than you.
Lucy:That doesn't make it hurt less.
Mr Haddad:No, I know. Right, let's start with the positives, because they're real. All three judges mentioned your tone in the slow movement of the Bruch. One of them wrote, "warm, singing sound, rare at sixteen".
Lucy:Really? I was shaking so much during that part, I thought you'd be able to hear it.
Mr Haddad:Not at all. That's the interesting thing. Your nerves didn't show in the slow music. They showed in the fast passage near the end, and in the scales.
Lucy:The scales. I knew it. I just wanted them to be over.
Mr Haddad:Exactly, and that's what they heard. You rushed. Your scale of D major started at a sensible speed and finished about twice as fast. And in the fast passage the rhythm became uneven. The notes were all there, but they weren't in the right places.
Lucy:At home I play it perfectly. Well, nearly perfectly.
Mr Haddad:I believe you. I've heard you do it in lessons. The problem isn't your fingers, it's what happens to them under pressure. And the good news is that's something you can train.
Lucy:How? I can't exactly practise being terrified.
Mr Haddad:Actually, you can. Two things. First, practise the fast sections with a metronome, slowly, and only speed up when you can play them three times in a row without a mistake. Boring, but it works.
Lucy:And the second?
Mr Haddad:Perform. As often as possible, in front of real people. The school concert in March, the old people's home on Thursdays, even your little brother and the cat. Every time you play for an audience, the pressure gets a bit more familiar.
Lucy:My brother's a terrible audience. He reviews everything.
Mr Haddad:Then he's perfect. The panel will be tougher than him, I promise. And record yourself, too. Listening back is painful, but it's the quickest way to hear what they hear.
Lucy:So you really think I should try again?
Mr Haddad:The auditions are next October. That gives you eleven months. If you'd asked me a year ago, I'd have said you weren't ready. Now you're close. That's a big leap in one year.
Lucy:Okay. I think I needed to hear that. On Friday I almost decided to give up the violin completely.
Mr Haddad:I'm glad you didn't. Half the professional players I know were turned down the first time. Rejection isn't the end, it's feedback with bad manners.
Lucy:Feedback with bad manners. I'm putting that on my music stand.
Mr Haddad:Good. Now, get your violin out. We'll start with D major. Slowly.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| panel/ˈpænəl/ | a small group of people who judge or decide something |
| tone/təʊn/ | the quality of the sound a musician makes |
| rushed/rʌʃt/ | went faster than you should |
| rhythm/ˈrɪðəm/ | the regular pattern of long and short sounds in music |
| under pressure/ˌʌndə ˈpreʃə/ | when you feel worried because something important depends on you |
| metronome/ˈmetrənəʊm/ | a machine that clicks at a steady speed to help musicians keep time |
| leap/liːp/ | a big jump or improvement |
| feedback/ˈfiːdbæk/ | comments that tell you what was good and what you can improve |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.