C2 American · Text 18
A Library for the City
An architecture critic reviews Seattle's new Lake Union Library on her podcast: the beautiful light, the baffling staircases, the noisy fourth floor and the $165 million question.
41 sentences · Tap a sentence to hear it again
Text
Welcome back to City Shapes. This week: the building that half of Seattle seems to have an opinion about, the new Lake Union Library, which opened its doors three weeks ago. I've been inside three times now: on a quiet Tuesday morning, on a packed Saturday afternoon, and on a rainy Thursday evening, which, this being Seattle, was not hard to arrange. And I've come away both dazzled and slightly irritated, which is, I suppose, what good architecture often does to me.
Let's begin with what works, because a great deal does. The architects have understood something about this city that a lot of buildings ignore: for much of the year, the light here is gray and low and precious. So the whole east side of the building is glass, angled to catch the morning sun, and the reading room on the third floor is lit from above by a long skylight running its full length. On my Tuesday visit, I watched an elderly man doing a crossword in a patch of sunlight with an expression of total contentment, and I thought, well, that's exactly what this building was meant to do. The chairs are generous, the tables are cedar, and there are little window seats where a teenager can fold herself up with a book and disappear for an afternoon. The children's floor, on level two, is cheerful without being patronizing, which is rarer than you'd think.
Now, the staircases. There are four of them, and individually they're beautiful: wide, wooden, almost sculptural. The problem is that they don't connect in any way a normal person can predict. The staircase from the lobby takes you to the second floor, but to reach the third you have to walk across the building to a different one, and the one that seems to lead to the fifth floor actually stops at the fourth. On Saturday, I counted seven people in ten minutes stopping a staff member to ask how to get somewhere. When the main thing people say about your stairs is "Excuse me, how do I get out of here?", something has gone wrong. The signs, which were clearly added in a hurry, are a polite admission of the fact.
And then there's the fourth floor. It holds the makerspace, with its 3-D printers and sewing machines, and the teen lounge, both lovely ideas. But it's an open floor with hard surfaces, and it sits directly under the quiet study area on five, connected to it by a large opening in the ceiling. Sound travels straight up. On Thursday evening, a group of perfectly well-behaved teenagers having a perfectly normal conversation could be heard by everyone upstairs who was trying to study for exams. That's not the teenagers' fault. It's an acoustic design failure, and it will be expensive to fix.
Which brings me to money. The building cost $165 million, most of it from a voter-approved levy. Critics have asked whether a city with real housing problems should spend that much on books in an age when, as they put it, everything's online. I understand the question. I just think it's based on a misunderstanding of what libraries do now.
On my Saturday visit, I saw people printing job applications, a man getting help with an immigration form, a toddler story hour with about forty families, a chess club, and a woman charging her phone while she waited for a bus. Almost none of them were borrowing books. A modern library isn't really a warehouse for paper. It's one of the last indoor public places where you can stay as long as you like without buying anything. That's not obsolete. If anything, it's more needed than ever.
So, my verdict. The Lake Union Library is a generous, light-filled building with a confused skeleton and a noisy heart. Its flaws are real, but they're mostly fixable, and its best qualities are things you simply can't add later. Go see it. Bring a book, or don't. Just give yourself some extra time to find the stairs.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| dazzled/ˈdæzəld/ | strongly impressed by something very beautiful or clever |
| skylight/ˈskaɪlaɪt/ | a window in a roof or ceiling |
| contentment/kənˈtentmənt/ | a calm, happy feeling of having all you need |
| patronizing/ˈpeɪtrənaɪzɪŋ/ | treating people as if they were less clever than they are |
| sculptural/ˈskʌlptʃərəl/ | shaped like a work of art made from wood, stone or metal |
| admission/ədˈmɪʃən/ | a statement that something bad or wrong is true |
| acoustic/əˈkuːstɪk/ | connected with sound and how it travels in a room |
| levy/ˈlevi/ | an extra local tax for a special purpose |
| obsolete/ˌɑːbsəˈliːt/ | no longer useful because something newer has replaced it |
| flaws/flɔːz/ | faults or weak points in something |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.