C2 American · Dialogue 8
The Bike Lane
At a library meeting in Minneapolis, a city planner, a hardware store owner and a college student argue about replacing forty parking spaces with a bike lane.
23 lines · Tap a line to hear it again
Dialogue
Karen Webb:Good evening, and thank you for coming out on a Tuesday in January. I know the parking lot is icy. I'm Karen Webb from the city's Public Works department. Tonight is about one proposal: a protected bike lane on Larkin Avenue, between 28th and 36th Street. We'd remove forty parking spaces on the east side and separate the lane from traffic with a low concrete curb. I see a hand already. Go ahead, sir.
Mr. Dennis Hall:Dennis Hall. I own Hall's Hardware on Larkin, and my family has run it for thirty-four years. I'll be blunt: those forty spaces are my customers. People don't carry two gallons of paint and a ladder home on a bicycle.
Karen Webb:That's a completely fair point, Mr. Hall, and we've heard it from several business owners. Can I ask roughly how many of your customers drive?
Mr. Dennis Hall:Most of them. I'd say eighty percent. Maybe more.
Karen Webb:Here's what's interesting, and I don't say this to dismiss you. When we surveyed shoppers on Larkin last summer, about forty-five percent had arrived by car. The rest walked, biked or took the bus. Store owners almost always overestimate how many customers drive.
Mr. Dennis Hall:With respect, a survey on a sunny afternoon in July isn't the same as a hardware store in February.
Karen Webb:No, it isn't, and that's a legitimate criticism. We should have surveyed in winter too, and we will.
Olivia:Can I say something? I'm Olivia, I'm a sophomore at the university, and I ride down Larkin to class four days a week. Last October, right outside the bakery, a driver opened his door without looking, and I had about half a second to swerve. I ended up in the traffic lane with a bus behind me.
Mr. Dennis Hall:Were you hurt?
Olivia:Just a bruised elbow and a broken bike light. But I was shaking for an hour. And the driver was really apologetic. He wasn't a bad person. The street is just designed so this keeps happening.
Karen Webb:Thank you, Olivia. What you're describing is called dooring, and it's exactly what this design prevents, because there'd be no parked cars on that side at all, just a curb between you and the traffic.
Mr. Dennis Hall:I'm genuinely sorry that happened to you, young lady. I mean that. I just can't see how my store survives if the people who keep it open can't park.
Karen Webb:Let me tell you about Halverson Avenue, the most similar street we have. Same width, same mix of small shops. We put a protected lane there in 2023 and removed thirty-two spaces. In the first year, sales at businesses along that stretch went up about four percent on average, compared with two percent across the city.
Mr. Dennis Hall:On average. Did any of them go down?
Karen Webb:Two did. I won't sugarcoat it. One was a tire shop, which you'd probably expect. The other one closed for reasons the owner told us had nothing to do with the lane.
Olivia:Could there be a loading zone outside the hardware store? So people can pull up, load the paint and go?
Karen Webb:That's actually in the plan already. There'd be a fifteen-minute loading zone right in front of Mr. Hall's store, and we'd change twenty-two spaces on the side streets from one-hour to two-hour parking.
Mr. Dennis Hall:A loading zone out front. Well, that's better than nothing. It's not forty spaces, but it's something I could work with. Who decides in the end?
Karen Webb:The city council votes on February twenty-fourth. Public comments are open until the end of January. And, Mr. Hall, I'd like to come to your store and count your customers myself, with you, for a week in February. If the numbers say we're wrong, that goes in my report.
Mr. Dennis Hall:You'd do that? Then I'll hold you to it. Come on a Saturday morning. That's when you'll see the real crowd.
Olivia:Maybe I'll come and buy a new bike light while you're counting.
Mr. Dennis Hall:Ha. Ten percent off for anyone who arrives by bicycle. Just don't tell the city I said that.
Karen Webb:I didn't hear a thing, Mr. Hall.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| curb/kɜːrb/ | the raised edge between a road and the place where people walk |
| blunt/blʌnt/ | saying exactly what you think, without trying to be polite |
| overestimate/ˌoʊvərˈestɪmeɪt/ | to think that a number is bigger than it really is |
| legitimate/ləˈdʒɪtəmət/ | fair and reasonable |
| sophomore/ˈsɑːfəmɔːr/ | a student in the second year of college or high school |
| swerve/swɜːrv/ | to change direction suddenly to avoid hitting something |
| bruised/bruːzd/ | with a dark mark on the skin after being hit |
| dooring/ˈdɔːrɪŋ/ | when a cyclist hits a car door that someone suddenly opens |
| sugarcoat/ˈʃʊɡərkoʊt/ | to make bad news sound better than it really is |
| hold you to it/ˌhoʊld juː ˈtuː ɪt/ | make sure that you do what you promised |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.