Eenglish-tests.com

C2 American · Dialogue 7

Is It Art?

Two podcast hosts in Los Angeles argue about whether pictures made with artificial intelligence can be called art.

28 lines · Tap a line to hear it again

Dialogue

B

Brian:Welcome back to Second Look, the show where we take one question and argue about it until we run out of coffee. I'm Brian.

L

Lena:And I'm Lena. This week's question came from about four hundred of you. Can an image made by artificial intelligence be called art?

B

Brian:And I'll put my cards on the table right away. No. It can be beautiful and impressive, but it isn't art, because nobody struggled to make it.

L

Lena:Here we go. Define struggle.

B

Brian:When a painter spends three weeks on a portrait, every brushstroke is a decision. They get it wrong, scrape it off, try again. With these tools, you type a sentence, wait twelve seconds, and get a finished picture.

L

Lena:You're measuring art by effort. I'd measure it by what happens to the person looking at it. If an image stops me in my tracks, does it matter whether it took three weeks or twelve seconds?

B

Brian:I think it does. Imagine a friend gives you a birthday poem, you're touched, and then you find out a computer wrote it in four seconds. Don't you feel a little cheated?

L

Lena:Honestly? A bit. But that's about my friend, not the poem. The poem is exactly as good as it was a minute earlier.

B

Brian:Is it, though? I'd argue the poem changed. Part of its meaning was that someone cared enough to write it.

L

Lena:Okay, that's a fair hit. Let's get to the story nearly everyone emailed about. A few years ago, an image made with AI won first prize in the digital art category at a state fair.

B

Brian:And some of the other artists were furious, and I don't blame them.

L

Lena:Though, to be fair to him, it wasn't twelve seconds. He said he'd spent around eighty hours on it, trying hundreds of prompts, and then he edited the final picture by hand. That's a lot of choosing.

B

Brian:Choosing isn't creating, though. A judge at a dog show chooses, but nobody says the judge made the dog.

L

Lena:Ha! But a photographer chooses too. Where to stand, when to press the button, which of two hundred shots to keep. And in the 1800s people said exactly that about photography: a machine did the work, so it couldn't be art.

B

Brian:I knew you'd bring up photography. Everybody brings up photography.

L

Lena:Because it's a good analogy!

B

Brian:It's a tempting one. But a photographer has to be there, in the rain, at five in the morning, waiting for the light. The camera captures something real. These image tools were trained on millions of pictures by real artists, most of whom were never asked and never paid.

L

Lena:Now that I agree with completely. I think it's the stronger argument, too: not whether the result is art, but whether it's fair to the people the machine learned from.

B

Brian:Common ground! Mark the date.

L

Lena:Here's where I've landed. The image itself can be art, because it can make you feel something. But the person who typed the prompt isn't an artist in the way a painter is. They're more like a curator, or, on a good day, a film director.

B

Brian:A director. I can live with that, mostly. A director has a vision and gets other people to carry it out. Except here the other people are a machine and a few million artists who never signed up for it.

L

Lena:You're not letting that go, are you?

B

Brian:I am not. If the effort disappears, I worry kids won't bother learning to draw. Why spend ten years getting good when a machine is instant?

L

Lena:My twelve-year-old niece draws every day and uses these tools to get ideas for poses. So I'm less pessimistic than you.

B

Brian:Then I hope she proves me wrong. Okay, listeners, your turn. Vote in the poll on our website by Sunday at midnight, Pacific time.

L

Lena:And send us your strangest arguments. The best one gets read out next week and wins a Second Look coffee mug.

B

Brian:Which, I should point out, was designed by a human.

L

Lena:By you. In about four minutes. See you next week!

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
put my cards on the table/ˌpʊt maɪ ˈkɑːrdz ɑːn ðə ˈteɪbəl/to say openly and honestly what I think
cheated/ˈtʃiːtɪd/treated unfairly, as if someone has tricked you
prompts/prɑːmpts/short written instructions that you type to tell a computer program what to make
analogy/əˈnælədʒi/a comparison that shows how two different things are alike
tempting/ˈtemptɪŋ/attractive and easy to accept, even if it may not be right
curator/ˈkjʊreɪtər/a person who chooses and arranges works of art for people to see
vision/ˈvɪʒən/a clear idea in your mind of how something should be
signed up/ˌsaɪnd ˈʌp/agreed to take part in something
pessimistic/ˌpesəˈmɪstɪk/expecting that bad things will happen

Tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.