1What the subjunctive looks like
The present subjunctive in English is simply the base form of the verb (the infinitive without to). It is the same for all persons, so there is no -s in the third person singular, and be stays be for every subject. It also does not change with tense: the same form is used whether the main verb is present or past. In most sentences, the subjunctive is only visible with he/she/it, with the verb be, or in the negative.
| Indicative (normal) | Subjunctive |
|---|---|
| She arrives on time. | …that she arrive on time. |
| He is informed. | …that he be informed. |
| They are not late. | …that they not be late. |
| The rule was changed. | …that the rule be changed. |
There are three kinds of subjunctive in modern English. The mandative subjunctive follows words expressing a demand or necessity (the main topic of this lesson). The formulaic subjunctive appears in fixed expressions (Long live…, Be that as it may). The were-subjunctive is the unreal past form you know from conditionals and wishes (If I were you…; I wish he were here), which we review briefly at the end.
2The mandative subjunctive after verbs
The mandative subjunctive follows verbs that express what someone wants to happen: a demand, a request, a recommendation, a proposal or an instruction. The that-clause describes an action that is desired, not a fact. That is why the verb does not show tense or person: the action has not happened and may never happen.
| Verb | Example |
|---|---|
| insist | The doctor insisted that he rest for at least a week. |
| recommend | The report recommends that the library remain open on Sundays. |
| suggest / propose | I propose that the meeting be postponed until March. |
| demand | Residents demanded that the council repair the bridge. |
| request / ask | The museum requests that visitors not touch the exhibits. (formal notices) |
| require | The regulations require that every passenger wear a seat belt. |
| urge / advise | We urge that the matter be treated with the utmost seriousness. |
- ✓
The judge ordered that the documents be returned to their owner.
- ✓
Her teacher suggested that she apply to the Royal College of Music.
- ✓
It was proposed that the new bridge be named after a local engineer.
- ✓
The coach insisted that nobody leave before the end of training.
- ✗
They demanded that he apologises.
In formal English, use the subjunctive: that he apologise (or that he should apologise).
3After adjectives and nouns
The same structure follows adjectives of necessity and importance (usually in the pattern It is + adjective + that…) and nouns related to the verbs above. This pattern is very frequent in official documents, academic writing, legal texts and formal speeches.
| Adjective / noun | Example |
|---|---|
| essential, vital, crucial | It is essential that every participant sign the consent form. |
| imperative, necessary | It is imperative that the patient not eat before the operation. |
| important, advisable, desirable | It is advisable that luggage be labelled clearly. |
| the recommendation that | The recommendation that the school be closed was rejected. |
| the insistence / demand that | Her insistence that every detail be checked saved the project. |
| on condition that | He was released on condition that he report to the police daily. |
- ✓
It is crucial that the experiment be repeated under controlled conditions.
- ✓
It is vital that nobody enter the building until it has been inspected.
- ✓
The requirement that applicants be over eighteen was strictly enforced.
- ✓
It is important that she knows about this.
also correct: indicative after important is common in everyday British English
4Negative and passive forms
The negative subjunctive is formed with not + base form, with no auxiliary do. Not comes directly before the verb. The passive subjunctive is be + past participle, and its negative is not be + past participle. These two forms are where advanced learners most often make mistakes, because they look so unusual.
| Form | Example |
|---|---|
| active | We recommend that he take the earlier flight. |
| active negative | We recommend that he not take the earlier flight. |
| passive | We recommend that the flight be cancelled. |
| passive negative | We recommend that the flight not be cancelled. |
- ✓
The committee proposed that the fee not be increased this year.
- ✓
The doctor advised that she not drive for six weeks.
- ✓
It is essential that all data be stored securely.
- ✗
They insisted that the vote doesn't take place.
Formal: that the vote not take place. Do is never used with the subjunctive.
- ✗
They asked that the results be not published.
Not goes before be: that the results not be published.
5Subjunctive, should or indicative? Register in British English
After these verbs, adjectives and nouns, British English offers three possibilities. The subjunctive is formal and is now normal in official, academic and legal texts on both sides of the Atlantic (it is more widespread in American English). Should + base form is a typically British alternative, natural in both formal and neutral styles. The ordinary indicative (present or past tense) is common in informal British English but is avoided in careful writing.
| Structure | Register | Example |
|---|---|---|
| subjunctive | formal; legal, academic, official | They recommended that she take a break. |
| should + base | neutral to formal; very British | They recommended that she should take a break. |
| indicative | informal British | They recommended that she took a break. |
| other structures | often more natural in speech | They recommended taking a break. / They advised her to take a break. |
The subjunctive and should-forms are interchangeable in meaning. However, the subjunctive is the safest choice in exams and formal writing, because it is accepted everywhere and avoids the informal ring of the indicative. In conversation, most British speakers would avoid the that-clause altogether: The doctor told him to rest. They suggested meeting later.
6No backshift: the same form in past contexts
Because the subjunctive has no tense, it does not change when the main verb is in the past. This is different from reported speech, where verbs normally shift back. Learners who have been carefully taught backshifting often wrongly apply it here.
| Present main verb | Past main verb |
|---|---|
| The rules require that she be present. | The rules required that she be present. (✗ was) |
| I insist that he come with us. | I insisted that he come with us. (✗ came, in formal English) |
| It is vital that they not know. | It was vital that they not know. (✗ didn't know) |
- ✓
The headteacher asked that every pupil bring a packed lunch on the trip.
- ✓
In 1900 it was considered essential that a young lady be accompanied in public.
- ✓
The council resolved that the old cinema be turned into a community centre.
7Insist and suggest: two meanings, two structures
Insist and suggest each have two meanings, and only one of them takes the subjunctive. When insist means 'demand that something happen', it takes the subjunctive. When it means 'say firmly that something is true', it takes the ordinary indicative, with normal tense and backshifting. In the same way, suggest meaning 'propose an action' takes the subjunctive, while suggest meaning 'indicate, imply' takes the indicative.
| Demand / propose → subjunctive | State / imply → indicative |
|---|---|
| He insisted that she stay for dinner. (he demanded it) | He insisted that she was innocent. (he said firmly it was true) |
| I suggest that he be told immediately. (my proposal) | The evidence suggests that he was at home. (it indicates) |
| The judge insisted that the witness answer the question. | The witness insisted that he had answered the question. |
- ✓
Her silence suggested that she disagreed.
imply → indicative
- ✓
My mum insisted that I phone her as soon as I landed.
demand → subjunctive
- ✗
The data suggest that the treatment be effective.
Suggest = indicate → indicative: the treatment is effective.
8Formulaic subjunctive: fixed expressions
The formulaic subjunctive survives in a number of fixed expressions inherited from older English. Their grammar cannot be changed or extended to other verbs: you cannot create new sentences on the same pattern. Most are formal or literary; some (Be that as it may, Suffice it to say, Come what may) are still common in educated speech and journalism.
| Expression | Meaning and example |
|---|---|
| God save the King | the national anthem and a traditional loyal formula; a fixed phrase |
| Long live…! | a wish for long life or long existence: Long live the free press! |
| Come what may | whatever happens: Come what may, we'll finish the marathon. |
| Be that as it may | even so, despite that: The plan is expensive. Be that as it may, it is the only option. |
| Suffice it to say | I'll only say this: Suffice it to say, the meeting did not go well. |
| Far be it from me to… | I don't want to criticise, but…: Far be it from me to tell you what to do, but… |
| Perish the thought | I hope that never happens (often humorous): Me, give a speech? Perish the thought! |
| So be it | I accept that, even if I don't like it: If that's your decision, so be it. |
| If need be | if necessary: We can work late, if need be. |
- ✓
Far be it from me to criticise your cooking, but this soup could do with a little salt.
- ✓
The company has lost money for three years. Be that as it may, the owners refuse to sell.
- ✓
If need be, we'll hire a minibus.
- ✓
Come what may, I'll be there for you.
song lyrics, speeches, promises
9Concessive be: be it…, whether it be…
In formal English, a subjunctive be at the start of a clause, or after whether, expresses 'it doesn't matter whether it is X or Y'. This pattern is literary and formal; in everyday English we use whether it's or whatever.
| Formal (subjunctive) | Everyday equivalent |
|---|---|
| Every citizen, be they rich or poor, has the right to vote. | Every citizen, whether they're rich or poor, … |
| Any change, be it large or small, must be approved. | Any change, whether it's large or small, … |
| Whether it be a novel or a poem, she reads it twice. | Whether it's a novel or a poem, … |
- ✓
All writing, be it fiction or journalism, benefits from careful editing.
- ✓
The museum welcomes every visitor, be they five or ninety-five.
10The were-subjunctive and lest
The past subjunctive survives only as were, used for all persons in unreal conditions and wishes. In formal English were is preferred (If I were you…, I wish she were here), while was is common in speech. Some fixed phrases allow only were: as it were (= so to speak), were it not for, were he to + verb (a formal inverted conditional). If I were you is the standard form of the advice phrase; if I was you is heard in casual speech but avoided in writing.
- ✓
If I were you, I'd apply for the scholarship.
- ✓
He became, as it were, the family's unofficial historian.
as it were = so to speak
- ✓
Were it not for the volunteers, the festival could not take place.
Lest is a very formal conjunction meaning 'so that… not' or 'for fear that'. It is followed by the subjunctive or by should. It appears in memorials (Lest we forget), in literary writing and in formal warnings. In everyday English use in case or so that… not.
| Formal | Everyday |
|---|---|
| She wrote the date down lest she forget it. | She wrote it down so that she wouldn't forget it. |
| He spoke quietly lest he should wake the baby. | He spoke quietly so that he wouldn't wake the baby. |