1The pattern: modal + have + past participle
The structure is the same as in past deduction (must have, might have): a modal verb, then have, then the past participle. Have never changes to has or had. The important thing to remember is that most of these forms talk about things that did not really happen. I should have phoned = I didn't phone (and that was a mistake). I could have phoned = it was possible, but I didn't.
| Form | What really happened? |
|---|---|
| I should have phoned. | I didn't phone. I regret it. |
| I shouldn't have shouted. | I shouted. I regret it. |
| I could have phoned. | I didn't phone, but it was possible. |
| I needn't have phoned. | I phoned, but it wasn't necessary. |
| I would have phoned (if I'd known). | I didn't phone, because of some condition. |
2Should have: regret
We use should have + past participle to say that something was the right thing to do, but we didn't do it. When we talk about ourselves, it expresses regret: we are sorry about our past actions or decisions. The negative shouldn't have means that we did something, and it was a mistake.
- ✓
I'm so tired. I should have gone to bed earlier. (I didn't.)
- ✓
We should have booked a table. The restaurant is full.
- ✓
I shouldn't have eaten so much chocolate. I feel sick. (I ate it.)
- ✓
I shouldn't have spent all my money on the first day of the holiday.
3Should have: criticism and advice after the event
When we talk about other people, should have and shouldn't have express criticism: we think they made a wrong choice. Because this can sound strong, we often soften it, for example with really, perhaps or maybe, or by using a gentler tone. We also use should have to say that something was expected but didn't happen.
- ✓
You should have told me you were ill. I would have helped.
- ✓
He shouldn't have driven so fast in the rain.
- ✓
Maybe you should have asked the teacher before you started.
- ✓
The parcel should have arrived yesterday. I'll call the shop. (It was expected but it didn't come.)
4Ought to have: a more formal should have
Ought to have + past participle means the same as should have. It is less common and sounds more formal or old-fashioned, but you will meet it in books, formal writing and official language. The negative is ought not to have (oughtn't to have is rare).
- ✓
The council ought to have repaired the road years ago.
- ✓
With hindsight, we ought to have consulted the residents first.
- ✓
You ought not to have left the children alone.
5Could have: missed possibilities
Could have + past participle means that something was possible in the past, but it didn't happen. We use it to talk about missed opportunities, lucky escapes, and other choices that someone could have made. It can also express criticism in a softer way than should have: You could have helped me! (= you didn't help, and I'm annoyed).
- ✓
We could have won the match if Jack hadn't missed that penalty. (missed chance)
- ✓
Be careful! You could have fallen off the ladder. (lucky escape)
- ✓
You could have phoned to say you'd be late! (criticism)
- ✓
She could have studied medicine, but she chose music instead. (another choice)
Couldn't have + past participle often means that something was impossible, even if we had tried. It is also used in common expressions with comparatives that mean 'it was the best / the worst possible'.
- ✓
I couldn't have done it without your help. (Your help was essential.)
- ✓
The weather couldn't have been better. (It was perfect.)
- ✓
We couldn't have arrived any earlier — the roads were blocked.
6Needn't have done vs didn't need to do
This is one of the most useful distinctions at B2. Both forms mean that something was not necessary. The difference is whether the action actually happened.
| Form | Did it happen? | Example |
|---|---|---|
| needn't have + past participle | Yes — it happened, but it was unnecessary (wasted effort) | I needn't have taken an umbrella. It didn't rain. (I took one.) |
| didn't need to + infinitive | Usually no — it wasn't necessary, so we didn't do it | I didn't need to take an umbrella, so I left it at home. |
- ✓
You needn't have bought milk — there were already two bottles in the fridge. (You bought it.)
- ✓
We needn't have hurried. The train was twenty minutes late. (We hurried.)
- ✓
I didn't need to cook last night because we went out for dinner. (I didn't cook.)
- ✓
She didn't need to show her passport — her ID card was enough. (She didn't show it.)
7Would have: imagined past results
Would have + past participle describes something we imagine happening in the past, but which didn't happen. It is the main clause of the third conditional (If I had known, I would have come), but we often use it without the if-clause when the condition is clear from the context. Wouldn't have is the negative.
- ✓
If you had asked me, I would have helped you.
- ✓
I would have called you, but my phone was dead. (I didn't call.)
- ✓
I loved the party. You would have enjoyed it too. (You weren't there.)
- ✓
I wouldn't have worried if I'd known you were safe.
| Form | Main idea |
|---|---|
| should have done | It was the right thing to do (but it didn't happen). |
| could have done | It was possible (but it didn't happen). |
| would have done | It was what I wanted or what was going to happen, under a condition (but it didn't happen). |
8Choosing the right form
Here is one situation with all the forms. Lena took the bus to the airport, and it took two hours. Read the comments and notice the different meanings.
| Comment | Meaning |
|---|---|
| She should have taken the train. | The train was the better choice; she didn't take it — regret or criticism. |
| She could have taken a taxi. | A taxi was possible, but she didn't take one. |
| She needn't have left so early. Her flight was delayed. | She left early, but it wasn't necessary. |
| She didn't need to check in online — she had no luggage. | Not necessary, so she didn't do it. |
| She would have arrived sooner by train. | Imagined result of a different choice. |
| She ought to have checked the timetable. | Formal version of should have. |