Eenglish-tests.com
B2

Past deduction: must have, can't have, might have

Often we don't know for certain what happened in the past, but we can make a logical guess based on the evidence. Her lights are off and she isn't answering the phone — she must have gone out. He walked straight past us — he can't have seen us. Maybe the bus was late — she might have missed it. These sentences use a modal verb + have + past participle, and the modal shows how sure we are. In this lesson you will learn the form, a scale of certainty from 'almost certainly yes' to 'almost certainly not', the continuous form (must have been sleeping), the difference between present and past deduction, and the most common learner mistakes.

1Form: modal + have + past participle

Subject + must / might / may / could / can't / couldn't + have + past participle

To make a deduction about the past, we keep the modal verb in the same form and add have + past participle (the third form: gone, seen, forgotten, left). The modal never changes: there is no 'musted' or 'had must'. The word have never changes either — it is have, even with he, she and it, because it follows a modal verb.

ModalExample
must haveShe must have forgotten about the meeting.
may haveThey may have taken the wrong road.
might haveHe might have left his phone at home.
could haveThe letter could have got lost in the post.
can't haveYou can't have finished already!
couldn't haveShe couldn't have known about the party.

2Must have: almost certainly yes

We use must have when the evidence makes us almost sure that something happened. It doesn't mean obligation here — it is a logical conclusion. We can't be 100% sure, because we didn't see it, but there is no other sensible explanation.

  • ✓

    The streets are wet. It must have rained in the night.

  • ✓

    You got 98% in the exam? You must have worked really hard.

  • ✓

    Ben isn't at his desk and his coat has gone. He must have gone home.

  • ✓

    I can't find my keys. I must have left them at the office.

3Can't have / couldn't have: almost certainly not

The opposite of must have is can't have or couldn't have. We use them when the evidence makes us almost sure that something did not happen or was impossible. The two forms mean nearly the same; couldn't have is slightly more common in stories and reported speech.

  • ✓

    He can't have seen us — he didn't even wave.

  • ✓

    You can't have spent all your money already! You only got it yesterday.

  • ✓

    She couldn't have taken the train: there were no trains because of the strike.

  • ✓

    That can't have been Anna you saw. She's in Australia this month.

4May have / might have / could have: possibly

When we think something is possible but we are not sure, we use may have, might have or could have. These three are very close in meaning. May have can sound a little more formal; might have is the most common in conversation; could have suggests that something was possible.

  • ✓

    Lucy is late. She might have missed the bus.

  • ✓

    I'm not sure where I put the receipt. I may have thrown it away.

  • ✓

    Someone could have taken your umbrella by mistake.

  • ✓

    The email might have gone into your spam folder.

The negatives might not have and may not have mean 'perhaps it didn't happen'. Notice that they are very different from can't have, which means 'I'm sure it didn't happen'.

SentenceMeaning
She might not have heard the doorbell.Perhaps she didn't hear it.
She can't have heard the doorbell.I'm sure she didn't hear it.

5The certainty scale

It helps to imagine the modals on a scale from 'almost certainly yes' to 'almost certainly not'. When you make a deduction, first decide how sure you are, then choose the modal.

How sure?ModalExample
About 95% yesmust haveThe lights are off. They must have gone to bed.
About 50% — possiblemay / might / could haveThey might have gone to bed.
About 50% — possibly notmay not / might not haveThey might not have gone to bed yet.
About 95% nocan't / couldn't haveThey can't have gone to bed — it's only eight o'clock.

6Continuous forms: must have been doing

Subject + modal + have been + verb-ing

When the deduction is about an action that was in progress at a moment in the past (not a completed action), we use the continuous form: modal + have been + -ing. Compare: She must have slept (a completed action) and She must have been sleeping (in the middle of sleeping at that moment).

  • ✓

    I phoned you at midnight but you didn't answer. You must have been sleeping.

  • ✓

    He can't have been listening — he didn't understand a single question.

  • ✓

    She looked very relaxed. She might have been reading a good book.

  • ✓

    The driver could have been using his phone when the accident happened.

Simple form (completed)Continuous form (in progress)
He must have finished work early.He must have been working when you called.
They might have seen the film.They might have been watching a film.

7Present deduction or past deduction?

You already know the present forms: She must be tired. He can't be at home. They might be busy. To move the deduction into the past, change the infinitive (be, know, work) into the perfect infinitive (have been, have known, have worked). The modal itself stays the same.

Present deductionPast deduction
She must be at work. (now)She must have been at work. (yesterday)
He can't know the answer.He can't have known the answer.
They might be lost.They might have got lost.
You must be joking!You must have been joking!
She could be sleeping.She could have been sleeping.
  • ✓

    Tom isn't answering. He must be in a meeting. (now)

  • ✓

    Tom didn't answer this morning. He must have been in a meeting. (in the past)

8Could have: deduction or missed chance?

Be careful: could have has two meanings. In this lesson it means 'possibly it happened' (a deduction). It can also mean 'it was possible, but it didn't happen' (a missed chance or a lucky escape). The context tells you which meaning is intended.

SentenceMeaning
Where's my wallet? I could have dropped it in the taxi.Deduction: perhaps I dropped it.
You could have hurt yourself! Be more careful.Missed possibility: it was possible, but you didn't get hurt.

9Common mistakes

Past deduction: must have, can't have, might have: tests

2 free tests and 8 Premium tests.

GameFix the mistake: Past deduction: must have, can't have, might haveFind the mistake in each sentence and choose the right word.Play →

Found this lesson useful? Share it with a friend or your class.