1What does a defining relative clause do?
Imagine you say: The woman is my aunt. Which woman? There are many women in the world. A defining relative clause answers this question: The woman who is talking to Dad is my aunt. Now we know exactly which woman. This information is necessary; if we take it away, the sentence loses its meaning.
| Without a relative clause | With a defining relative clause |
|---|---|
| I like the boy. (Which boy?) | I like the boy who sits next to me. |
| Where is the cake? (Which cake?) | Where is the cake that I made? |
| That's the shop. (Which shop?) | That's the shop where I bought my shoes. |
A relative clause can also join two short sentences into one longer, more natural sentence. The relative pronoun replaces a word in the second sentence.
| Two sentences | One sentence |
|---|---|
| I have a friend. She speaks four languages. | I have a friend who speaks four languages. |
| This is the book. I told you about it. | This is the book that I told you about. |
| We stayed in a hotel. It had a big pool. | We stayed in a hotel which had a big pool. |
2who and that for people
We use who for people. We can also use that for people, especially in conversation. who is a little more common and sounds a little more careful in writing.
- ✓
A vet is a person who looks after animals.
- ✓
The girl who won the race is in my class.
- ✓
I've got a cousin that lives in Canada.
- ✓
The people who live next door are very friendly.
- ✓
Do you know the man who is standing by the door?
3which and that for things
We use which or that for things and animals. In defining relative clauses both are correct and have the same meaning. In everyday British English, that is very common; which is also used, especially in writing.
- ✓
This is the train that goes to Edinburgh.
- ✓
I lost the watch which my grandad gave me.
- ✓
A fridge is a machine that keeps food cold.
- ✓
Where are the biscuits which were in this tin?
- ✓
She wrote a story that won a prize.
Quick choice
| We talk about | Use |
|---|---|
| people | who or that |
| things and animals | which or that |
4where for places, when for times
We use where after a place (a town, a house, a room, a shop, a park) when the clause tells us what happens in that place. where means 'in which' or 'at which'. We use when after time words (the day, the year, the time, the moment, the summer).
| Pronoun | Example | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| where | This is the house where I grew up. | I grew up in this house. |
| where | Do you know a café where we can get breakfast? | We can get breakfast at the café. |
| where | That's the hospital where I was born. | I was born in that hospital. |
| when | I remember the day when we met. | We met on that day. |
| when | Summer is the time when most people go on holiday. | People go on holiday at that time. |
Be careful: we use where only when a full clause with its own subject follows: the town where we live. If the place is the subject of the clause, use which or that.
- ✓
This is the restaurant where we had my birthday dinner.
we had dinner there → where
- ✓
This is the restaurant that opened last week.
the restaurant opened → it is the subject → that / which
- ✗
This is the museum where has dinosaur bones.
The museum is the subject: the museum which / that has dinosaur bones.
5whose for possession
whose shows that something belongs to the person (or thing) before it. It replaces his, her, its or their. whose is always followed by a noun.
| Two sentences | One sentence with whose |
|---|---|
| I have a friend. Her dad is a famous chef. | I have a friend whose dad is a famous chef. |
| That's the boy. His bike was stolen. | That's the boy whose bike was stolen. |
| We met a couple. Their children go to my school. | We met a couple whose children go to my school. |
- ✓
The woman whose car is parked outside is our new teacher.
- ✓
I know a girl whose brother plays for Arsenal.
- ✗
I know a girl who her brother plays for Arsenal.
Use whose instead of who + her.
6Subject or object? Leaving out the pronoun
Look at what the relative pronoun does in its clause. If it is the subject (it does the action), we must keep it. If it is the object (someone else does the action to it), we can leave it out. This is very common in spoken English.
| The pronoun is… | Example | Can we leave it out? |
|---|---|---|
| the subject | the girl who lives next door (she lives) | No — ✗ the girl lives next door |
| the subject | the bus that goes to the airport (it goes) | No |
| the object | the book (that) I read (I read it) | Yes: the book I read |
| the object | the man (who) we met (we met him) | Yes: the man we met |
An easy test: if a noun or pronoun (I, you, we, my sister…) comes straight after the relative pronoun, the pronoun is the object and you can leave it out. If a verb comes straight after it, the pronoun is the subject and you must keep it.
- ✓
The cake (that) you made was delicious.
you made it → object → that is optional
- ✓
Is this the bag (which) you lost?
- ✓
The people (who) we met on holiday were from Wales.
- ✓
The man who called you is waiting outside.
who + verb → subject → we must keep who.
- ✗
The man called you is waiting outside.
who is the subject here, so we can't leave it out.
7No extra pronoun
The relative pronoun already replaces the person or thing. So we don't repeat it with he, she, it, him, her or them inside the clause. This mistake is very common, especially when the relative pronoun is left out.
- ✗
The man who I met him was very kind.
who already means him: The man who I met was very kind.
- ✗
This is the phone that I bought it last week.
Remove it: the phone that I bought last week.
- ✗
The girl who she sits next to me is Polish.
Remove she: The girl who sits next to me is Polish.
- ✗
The film we watched it was scary.
Even without that, don't add it: The film we watched was scary.
- ✓
The film we watched was scary.
Correct.
8Prepositions at the end
Many verbs go with a preposition: live in, talk about, listen to, look for, wait for, work with. In everyday English, the preposition stays with its verb at the end of the relative clause. Very often we also leave out the pronoun.
| Two sentences | One sentence |
|---|---|
| This is the house. I live in it. | This is the house (that) I live in. |
| That's the girl. I told you about her. | That's the girl (who) I told you about. |
| Here's the song. I was listening to it. | Here's the song (that) I was listening to. |
| Did you find the keys? You were looking for them. | Did you find the keys (that) you were looking for? |
| He's a person. I enjoy working with him. | He's a person (who) I enjoy working with. |
9that or which?
In defining relative clauses, that and which usually mean the same for things, and you can choose either. Here is a short summary of the differences.
| Situation | that | which |
|---|---|---|
| Things in defining clauses | ✓ (very common) | ✓ |
| People | ✓ (informal) | ✗ |
| After something, everything, nothing, all | ✓ (best choice) | less common |
| After a superlative (the best…) | ✓ (best choice) | less common |
| After a preposition | ✗ | ✓ (formal): in which |
| With commas (non-defining, B2) | ✗ | ✓ |
- ✓
The bike that / which I want is too expensive.
- ✓
Everything that she said was true.
- ✓
It's the most beautiful place that I've ever visited.