1What is a collocation, and what is an argument?
A collocation is a combination of words that native speakers habitually use together. We say heavy rain, not strong rain, and in the same way we put forward an argument, not bring an argument. The unusual combination is normally understood, but it sounds foreign to a native speaker, because they have heard the standard version many times and the other one almost never. In persuasive writing and speaking this matters a great deal: if your language sounds unnatural, your audience is distracted and your argument loses some of its force.
First, notice that argument has two meanings. In everyday conversation, an argument is often a disagreement, sometimes an angry one: My brother and I had an argument about the remote control. In this lesson, an argument usually means a reason or set of reasons that you give to show that something is true or right: There is a strong argument for a longer lunch break. The collocations are different for each meaning, so the context always matters.
Two meanings of argument
| Meaning | Typical collocations | Example |
|---|---|---|
| a disagreement | have an argument with someone about something; a heated argument | They had a heated argument about whose turn it was to wash up. |
| reasons to support a view | put forward / present an argument for / against; a strong argument | She put forward a strong argument for recycling at school. |
- ✓
The students put forward several arguments in favour of a school garden.
- ✗
The students brought several arguments in favour of a school garden.
A literal translation. Use put forward, present, give or make an argument.
- ✓
We had a discussion about the new timetable.
- ✗
We made a discussion about the new timetable.
We have or hold a discussion; we do not make one.
2Presenting your position
When you start to argue, you first need to state where you stand. You can hold a view (have an opinion), express or voice it (say it), and take a position or take a stand on an issue (decide which side you are on, often publicly). You then put forward or present an argument, make a case for something (argue that it should happen) and make a point (express one particular idea). Notice how many of these use make or put, but in different combinations.
| Collocation | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| put forward an argument / idea / proposal | suggest it for people to consider | Several students put forward the idea of a car-free day. |
| present / advance an argument | give it formally (advance is very formal) | The essay presents two arguments against homework at weekends. |
| make a case for / against | give reasons why something should or should not happen | She made a strong case for longer school holidays. |
| make a point | express a particular idea in a discussion | You make a good point about the cost. |
| hold a view / an opinion | have a particular opinion | Many people hold the view that children should learn to cook. |
| express / voice a view / concern | say what you think (voice is a little more formal) | Parents voiced concerns about the busy road. |
| take a position / a stand on | decide and say publicly what you think | The council has not yet taken a position on the new park. |
| argue that / argue for / against | give reasons that something is true / should happen | Some people argue that uniforms reduce bullying. |
| be in favour of | support an idea | Most of the class were in favour of a trip to the museum. |
| be opposed to | disagree with an idea, often strongly | Local residents are opposed to the plan. |
Watch the grammar after be opposed to: the word to is a preposition here, so it is followed by a noun or an -ing form, not by an infinitive: I am opposed to building a new car park, not opposed to build. The same is true of object to: Many people object to paying for plastic bags.
3Strong and weak arguments
Arguments are judged by how convincing they are, and English has a rich set of adjectives for this. A compelling, convincing, persuasive or powerful argument makes people believe you. A sound or valid argument is logical and well reasoned. A fair or valid point is one that the other side has to accept. At the other end, a weak, flimsy or unconvincing argument is easy to reject, and a flawed argument contains a mistake in its logic.
| Collocation | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| a compelling case / argument | so convincing that you have to accept it | The report makes a compelling case for more cycle lanes. |
| a convincing / persuasive argument | an argument that makes people believe it | She gave a persuasive argument for a school vegetable garden. |
| a powerful / strong argument | a very effective argument | Safety is a powerful argument against the plan. |
| a sound argument | logical and based on good judgement | His reasoning is sound, but his facts are out of date. |
| a valid / fair point | a reasonable point that should be accepted | That's a fair point: the bus is more expensive. |
| a weak / flimsy argument | not convincing, easy to reject | "Everyone else does it" is a flimsy argument. |
| a flawed argument | an argument with a mistake in its logic | The argument is flawed because it ignores the cost. |
| hold water | (of an argument) be logical and believable | His excuse doesn't hold water: the shop was open. |
| stand up to scrutiny | remain convincing when examined carefully | Their claims do not stand up to scrutiny. |
| carry weight | be important and influence people | Her opinion carries a lot of weight with the head teacher. |
Hold water and stand up to scrutiny are almost always used in the negative or in questions: The theory doesn't hold water. Does this argument stand up to scrutiny? Carry weight is used about opinions, evidence and arguments that influence people: Evidence from experts carries more weight than personal stories.
4Using evidence
A good argument rests on evidence. Before deciding, a careful thinker weighs up the evidence: considers carefully the facts on both sides, as if putting them on a pair of scales. Evidence supports a claim or backs it up; you provide, produce or cite evidence; and evidence can be overwhelming (so strong that it cannot be ignored) or merely anecdotal (based on personal stories, not careful research).
| Collocation | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| weigh up the evidence / the pros and cons | consider the facts on both sides carefully | Let's weigh up the pros and cons before we decide. |
| back up / support a claim | give evidence that it is true | Can you back up that claim with any facts? |
| provide / produce evidence | show evidence | The scientists produced evidence that the river was cleaner. |
| cite an example / a study | mention it as support | She cited several examples from her own school. |
| overwhelming evidence | very strong evidence | There is overwhelming evidence that smoking is harmful. |
| anecdotal evidence | evidence from personal stories, not research | His argument relies on anecdotal evidence from his friends. |
| a lack of evidence | not enough evidence | The idea was rejected because of a lack of evidence. |
| the evidence points to | the evidence suggests | All the evidence points to a simple mistake. |
| draw on experience / research | use it as a source of support | The writer draws on her experience as a teacher. |
| on the basis of | using something as the reason | Don't judge a book on the basis of its cover. |
Notice the phrase the pros and cons: the advantages (pros) and the disadvantages (cons) of something. It is used with weigh up, consider and discuss: We discussed the pros and cons of a four-day week. Also remember, once more, that evidence is uncountable: some evidence, a piece of evidence, much evidence, but never an evidence or evidences.
5Responding to other views
A mature argument does not ignore the other side. You can acknowledge an opposing view (show that you know about it), concede a point (admit that the other person is right about one thing), see or take someone's point (understand and partly accept it), and then counter or challenge the argument (reply to it with an argument of your own). If you show clearly that an argument is false, you refute it. When neither side can persuade the other, people agree to differ, which is the more traditional British phrase; agree to disagree is also very common.
| Collocation | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| acknowledge an opposing view | show that you are aware of it | A good essay acknowledges the opposing view. |
| concede a point | admit that the other side is right about one thing | I'll concede that point: the bus is cheaper. |
| take / see someone's point | understand and partly accept it | I take your point, but I still think it's too far. |
| challenge / dispute a claim | question whether it is true | Many scientists dispute this claim. |
| counter an argument | reply to it with an opposite argument | She countered the argument with clear figures. |
| refute an argument / a claim | prove that it is wrong (formal) | The new study refutes the claim completely. |
| raise an objection (to) | say formally that you disagree | Nobody raised any objections to the plan. |
| a counter-argument | an argument against another argument | Now consider the main counter-argument. |
| play devil's advocate | argue the opposite side to test an idea | I agree with you, but let me play devil's advocate for a moment. |
| find common ground | find points that both sides agree on | The two groups managed to find common ground. |
| reach a compromise | agree by each side accepting less than it wanted | In the end, we reached a compromise: pizza on Friday, pasta on Saturday. |
| agree to differ / disagree | accept that you will not agree | We'll never agree about football, so let's agree to differ. |
Be careful with refute. In strict use it means to prove that something is wrong, not just to say it is wrong; for the weaker meaning, use deny, reject or dispute. Notice also the British spelling of counter-argument (often with a hyphen) and the pattern I take your point, but…, which is a polite, typically British way to accept part of someone's argument before disagreeing.
6Structuring a balanced argument
In an essay or a debate speech, a set of fixed phrases guides the reader through your reasoning. They tell the reader whether you are adding a point, contrasting two sides, conceding something or reaching a conclusion. Most of them are fixed: you cannot change their words or articles.
| Phrase | Use | Example |
|---|---|---|
| On the one hand… on the other hand | compare two sides | On the one hand, phones are useful; on the other hand, they can be distracting. |
| It could be argued that | introduce a view politely, often not your own | It could be argued that homework teaches discipline. |
| It is widely believed that | report a common opinion | It is widely believed that reading before bed helps you sleep. |
| There is no denying that | admit that something is clearly true | There is no denying that cars are convenient. |
| Admittedly, | concede a point before disagreeing | Admittedly, the plan is expensive. However, … |
| That said, | introduce a contrast after a point | The trip was tiring. That said, we learnt a lot. |
| The fact remains that | insist on a point despite other arguments | The fact remains that the road is dangerous. |
| On balance, | after considering all the arguments | On balance, I think the benefits outweigh the costs. |
| All things considered, | taking everything into account | All things considered, it was a fair decision. |
| In the light of | because of (new information) | In the light of these results, the plan should change. |
| the benefits outweigh the drawbacks | the advantages are greater than the disadvantages | In my view, the benefits of a school garden outweigh the drawbacks. |
Here is a short paragraph that uses several of these collocations. Notice how it presents a view, acknowledges the other side and reaches a balanced conclusion.
- ✓
Many people hold the view that schools should start later in the morning.
- ✓
Supporters put forward a compelling case: teenagers need more sleep, and there is a growing body of evidence to back up this claim.
- ✓
Admittedly, a later start would cause problems for some working parents, and this is a valid point.
- ✓
On balance, however, the benefits for students' health appear to outweigh the drawbacks.
7Argument, case, point, claim: similar words, different partners
These four nouns all belong to the language of argument, but they have different meanings and choose different verbs and adjectives. Compare them carefully.
| Noun | Meaning and typical partners | Example |
|---|---|---|
| argument | reasons for a view; put forward, present, win / lose an argument; a strong, compelling argument | She won the argument with one simple fact. |
| case | the whole set of reasons for one side; make / build / present a case; a compelling, strong case | They built a strong case for a new library. |
| point | one single idea or detail; make / raise / take / concede a point; a fair, valid, good point | You've raised an interesting point. |
| claim | a statement that may not be true; make / back up / dispute / reject a claim; a bold claim | The advert makes some very bold claims. |
Other pairs that learners confuse
| Say | Not | Why |
|---|---|---|
| put forward an argument | bring an argument | bring is a literal translation |
| have / hold a discussion | make a discussion | discussions are had or held |
| discuss a problem | discuss about a problem | discuss takes a direct object; talk about takes about |
| in my view / in my opinion | according to me | according to is used for other people and sources |
| raise a point / an objection | rise a point | raise has an object; rise has no object (prices rise) |
| a strong argument | a heavy argument | arguments are strong, powerful or compelling |
The difference between persuade and convince is worth knowing at C1. Persuade is used mainly for actions: She persuaded me to join the choir. Convince is used mainly for beliefs: He convinced me that he was right. In modern English, convince someone to do something is also common, but persuade is the safer choice in formal writing. Similarly, say, tell and speak need care: you make or raise a point (not say a point), you tell someone your opinion, and you speak in favour of or against a proposal in a debate.
8Common mistakes
Here are more of the errors that teachers and examiners see most often from Russian and Ukrainian speakers in argumentative writing. Most of them come from translating a phrase word for word.
9How to remember
To practise, choose a simple, everyday question, such as "Should pupils have a longer lunch break?", and write one paragraph for each side. Then write a conclusion that begins with On balance. Try to use at least eight collocations from this lesson, and underline them. Afterwards, read your paragraph aloud: if a phrase sounds heavy or unnatural, check its partner words in the tables above.
Learn these by heart
| Verb + noun | Adjective + noun / fixed phrase |
|---|---|
| put forward an argument | a compelling case |
| make a case for | a valid / fair point |
| weigh up the evidence | overwhelming evidence |
| back up a claim | doesn't hold water |
| concede a point | on balance |
| reach a compromise | the benefits outweigh the drawbacks |