1What hedging is and why we use it
A hedge is a word or phrase that shows how certain you are. Compare two sentences: Homework improves results. Homework tends to improve results. The first sentence is a strong, general claim, and a careful reader will immediately think of exceptions. The second sentence says the same thing, but it admits that it is not true in every case. It is more accurate, and therefore more convincing.
Writers hedge for three main reasons. First, accuracy: very few statements about people, society or science are true one hundred per cent of the time. Second, honesty about evidence: if you have read one study, you cannot claim to know the final truth. Third, politeness and respect for other opinions: a hedged claim leaves room for the reader to disagree, which sounds more reasonable than a statement that sounds like an order. In essays, reports and formal emails, hedging is a sign of a mature, careful writer, not of a weak one.
The same idea, from strong to careful
| Strong claim | Hedged claim |
|---|---|
| Video games cause aggression. | Some studies suggest that violent video games may be linked to short-term aggression. |
| Students hate exams. | Many students tend to find exams stressful. |
| The plan failed because of poor planning. | It would appear that the plan failed largely because of poor planning. |
| Online learning is better. | Online learning is arguably more flexible, although it has drawbacks. |
| Prices will rise next year. | It is likely that prices will rise next year. |
Hedging can be done with many kinds of words: verbs (seem, appear, tend, suggest), modal verbs (may, might, could, would), adverbs (probably, arguably, possibly), adjectives (likely, possible, probable), nouns (a possibility, a tendency), and phrases that limit a claim (to some extent, in many cases). The sections below look at each group.
2Verbs: seem, appear, tend to, suggest, indicate
Some verbs present a claim as an impression or a pattern rather than a fact. Seem and appear mean that something looks true from the evidence you have; appear is a little more formal. Tend to means that something usually happens, but not always. Suggest and indicate are used for evidence: data, results and research suggest or indicate something, which is more careful than prove or show.
| Instead of | Try | Example |
|---|---|---|
| X is … | X seems to be … / X appears to be … | The new timetable appears to be working well. |
| X always happens | X tends to happen | Younger children tend to learn languages through play. |
| the results prove that … | the results suggest that … | The results suggest that sleep affects memory. |
| the data show that … | the data indicate that … | The figures indicate a slight fall in sales. |
| X caused Y | X may have contributed to Y | Bad weather may have contributed to the low attendance. |
- ✓
Customers seem to prefer the smaller size.
- ✓
The museum appears to have been built on the site of an older church.
- ✓
British summers tend to be quite unpredictable.
- ✓
Early findings suggest that the scheme has been a success.
- ✓
This would seem to indicate that the problem is not as serious as we feared.
a double hedge: very cautious, typical of reports
Notice the difference in strength between show, prove, suggest and indicate. Prove means there is no doubt at all, so it is rarely the right verb for one survey or one experiment. Show is fairly strong. Indicate and suggest are the safest choices when you report research: The survey suggests that most parents support the idea.
3Modal verbs: may, might, could, would
Modal verbs are the simplest and most common hedging tools. May and might show that something is possible; might is slightly less certain. Could shows a possibility, often one that you want the reader to consider. Would makes a statement sound tentative and polite, especially with verbs such as suggest, argue and appear.
| Modal | What it adds | Example |
|---|---|---|
| may | a real possibility; neutral, very common in academic writing | This approach may reduce costs. |
| might | a weaker possibility | The change might confuse some users at first. |
| could | a possibility worth considering | Smaller classes could improve results. |
| would | makes a claim or an opinion sound tentative | I would argue that the benefits outweigh the costs. |
| may / might / could have + past participle | a possible explanation of the past | The parcel may have been sent to the wrong address. |
- ✓
Longer school days may not be the best solution.
- ✓
Some readers might find the ending disappointing.
- ✓
One reason for the decline could be the rise in rents.
- ✓
It would seem that the original plan was too ambitious.
- ✓
I would suggest that the meeting be moved to Friday.
very formal: suggest that + base form
4Adverbs: arguably, possibly, presumably, apparently
Hedging adverbs show your attitude to the claim. They are short and flexible, so they are very useful, but each one has its own exact meaning. Choose the one that matches the kind of uncertainty you have in mind.
| Adverb | Exact meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| probably /ˈprɒbəbli/ | very likely, but not certain | This is probably the most popular route. |
| possibly /ˈpɒsəbli/ | perhaps; less likely than probably | The delay was possibly caused by the strike. |
| arguably /ˈɑːɡjuəbli/ | you can give good reasons for this claim, though not everyone will agree | It is arguably the best novel of the decade. |
| presumably /prɪˈzjuːməbli/ | you think it is true because it is logical, but you have not checked | The office is closed, so they have presumably gone home. |
| apparently /əˈpærəntli/ | according to what you have heard or read; it seems so | Apparently, the bridge will be closed for repairs. |
| seemingly /ˈsiːmɪŋli/ | it looks true on the surface (but may not be) | The task was seemingly simple, but it took all day. |
| generally / largely / mainly | in most cases, mostly, not completely | The response has been largely positive. |
| relatively / fairly / somewhat | softens an adjective | The test was relatively easy. |
Arguably is a particularly elegant C1 word. It is often placed directly before a superlative or a strong adjective: arguably the most important invention, arguably more useful. It tells the reader: this is my view, I can defend it, but I accept that it can be debated. Apparently is different from the other adverbs: it often reports what someone else has said. In conversation, Apparently, it's going to snow means I heard this, I am not sure it is true.
- ✓
The castle is arguably the town's greatest attraction.
- ✓
You have presumably read the instructions already.
- ✓
Apparently, the new library will open in the spring.
- ✓
The results were somewhat disappointing.
- ✓
The problem probably won't disappear on its own.
5Likely, possible and probable: phrases of likelihood
Adjectives and nouns of likelihood allow you to express exactly how probable something is. They are very common in reports and essays, but their grammar is tricky, because the words that look similar do not always follow the same patterns.
| Phrase | Pattern and example |
|---|---|
| it is likely that … | It is likely that the price of energy will rise. |
| be likely to + verb | Energy prices are likely to rise. |
| it is unlikely that … / be unlikely to | The weather is unlikely to improve before Sunday. |
| it is possible that … | It is possible that the email went to the spam folder. |
| it is probable that … (formal) | It is probable that the fire started in the kitchen. |
| there is a (strong / slight) possibility that … | There is a slight possibility that the match will be cancelled. |
| there is some evidence that … | There is some evidence that music helps concentration. |
| in all likelihood (formal) | In all likelihood, the project will be finished on time. |
The important point is that likely can be used with a person or thing as the subject (She is likely to win), but possible and probable cannot. You cannot say She is possible to win or She is probable to win. With possible and probable, use the it-pattern: It is possible that she will win. It is probable that she will win. You can make all these phrases stronger or weaker with adverbs: highly likely, quite likely, very unlikely, entirely possible.
- ✓
Fewer people are likely to travel abroad this year.
- ✓
It is highly unlikely that the shop will reopen.
- ✓
It is entirely possible that we have made a mistake in the calculation.
- ✗
The museum is possible to close next month.
possible cannot take this pattern. Say: The museum is likely to close / It is possible that the museum will close.
6Limiting a claim: to some extent, in many cases
Sometimes the problem is not certainty but scope: a claim is true, but only partly, or only for some people, or only in some situations. Limiting phrases make the scope clear. They are extremely useful in discursive essays, where you agree with a statement only partly.
| Instead of | Try | Example |
|---|---|---|
| I agree. | I agree to some extent. / to a certain extent | To some extent, technology has made us lazier. |
| This is true. | This is true to a large extent / to a limited extent | The plan was successful to a limited extent. |
| People think … | Many / Some / Most people think … | Many people believe that cities are too crowded. |
| This always happens. | This happens in many cases / in some cases | In many cases, the cheaper option lasts longer. |
| In general … | Broadly speaking, … / On the whole, … | On the whole, the reviews were positive. |
| It is completely … | It is partly / in part … | The success of the event was partly due to the weather. |
| In every way … | In many ways, … / In some respects, … | In some respects, village life is easier. |
- ✓
I agree to a certain extent that exams are stressful, but they also motivate students.
- ✓
The town has changed to a great degree since the factory closed.
- ✓
Broadly speaking, the scheme has been popular with local families.
- ✓
Online shopping is, in some respects, more convenient than going to the shops.
Quantifiers are also hedges. Compare Teenagers spend too much time online with Many teenagers spend too much time online, or with A significant number of teenagers spend too much time online. The second and third versions are not weaker arguments; they are more accurate ones, and a reader is more likely to accept them.
7Impersonal structures: it would appear that, it could be argued
In formal writing we often present a claim impersonally, without I. This makes the text sound objective and allows you to introduce an idea that you may later criticise. These structures are formal: they suit essays, reports and academic writing, but they would sound strange in a chat with a friend.
| Structure | Use and example |
|---|---|
| it would appear that … / it would seem that … | a cautious conclusion: It would appear that the survey was too small. |
| it could be argued that … | introduces an argument (often one you will discuss): It could be argued that uniforms limit self-expression. |
| it is widely believed / thought that … | a common opinion: It is widely believed that breakfast is the most important meal. |
| X is thought / believed / said to + verb | the subject comes first: The house is thought to be over 300 years old. |
| there is a case for + -ing / noun | a reasonable argument exists: There is a case for lowering the price. |
| this may / might be due to … | a possible cause: This may be due to the cold weather. |
| one possible explanation is that … | offers a cause without claiming it is the only one: One possible explanation is that the instructions were unclear. |
- ✓
It would appear that fewer young people are learning to drive.
- ✓
It could be argued that public transport should be free for students.
- ✓
The painting is believed to have been lost during a fire.
past: be believed to have + past participle
- ✓
There is a strong case for building more cycle lanes.
- ✓
One possible explanation is that the questions were too difficult.
8How strong is your claim? A scale
A good writer chooses the strength of each claim on purpose. The scale below goes from complete certainty to weak possibility. Use the top only for facts you can really prove, the middle for most arguments, and the bottom for ideas you want to mention without supporting strongly.
From certain to possible
| Strength | Typical language | Example |
|---|---|---|
| certain (a fact) | is, will, clearly, undoubtedly | Water boils at 100 degrees Celsius at sea level. |
| very probable | is highly likely to, almost certainly, in all likelihood | The road will almost certainly be closed. |
| probable | is likely to, probably, tends to | Prices are likely to rise. |
| fairly probable / an impression | seems to, appears to, it would appear that | The method appears to work. |
| possible | may, could, possibly, it is possible that | This may explain the delay. |
| weak possibility | might, there is a slight possibility that | It might rain later. |
There is also the opposite of hedging: boosting. Words such as clearly, undoubtedly, it is evident that and there is no doubt that make a claim stronger. Boosters are fine when your evidence is really strong, but a text full of them sounds overconfident, and a careful examiner will notice when you write clearly about something that is not clear at all.
9Before and after
Here is a paragraph from an essay about reading habits. Every claim is presented as a certain fact. Then you can see the same paragraph with careful hedging.
- ✓
Before: Young people do not read books any more. They prefer their phones, and this is the reason why their vocabulary is worse than before. Libraries are useless now. Schools must make students read more, and then the problem will disappear.
- ✓
After: Young people appear to read fewer books than previous generations did. Many of them seem to prefer reading on their phones, and this may be one reason why some teachers report weaker vocabulary. Libraries, arguably, have a different role now, but they are still valuable. If schools encouraged students to read more, the problem would be likely to become less serious, at least to some extent.
Notice what has changed. Appear to turns a fact into an observation. Many and some limit the claims to part of the group. May and one reason admit that there could be other causes. Arguably shows a view that the writer can defend. At least to some extent avoids promising a complete solution. The paragraph is not weaker: it is more accurate, more reasonable and more difficult to disagree with.
10Common mistakes
11How to remember
Your hedging toolkit
| Kind of hedge | Words and phrases |
|---|---|
| verbs | seem, appear, tend to, suggest, indicate |
| modal verbs | may, might, could, would |
| adverbs | probably, possibly, arguably, presumably, apparently, largely |
| likelihood | it is likely that, be likely to, it is possible that, in all likelihood |
| limiting phrases | to some extent, in many cases, on the whole, in some respects |
| impersonal | it would appear that, it could be argued that, is thought to |
Learn the patterns together with the words: tend to + verb, be likely to + verb, it is possible that, to some extent, it seems to me, is thought to have + past participle. When you edit an essay, underline every strong claim and decide on purpose whether it needs a hedge.