Few words have wandered as far from home as 'nostalgia', which is fitting, since homecoming is what the word is about. It was coined in 1688 by Johannes Hofer, a Swiss medical student, who joined two Greek words, one meaning 'return home' and the other 'pain', to name a condition he had observed in people living far from their native valleys, among them Swiss soldiers serving abroad. The symptoms he recorded were alarming: sleeplessness, loss of appetite, fever and a listless sadness. For more than a century afterwards, doctors treated nostalgia as a disease, and prescribed for it everything from rest to a journey home.
Miriam Hale's absorbing new book, The Backward Glance, begins with this curious medical history before following the word on its long journey from the sickroom to the shopping centre. Today nostalgia is less often diagnosed than sold. Record shops that once seemed doomed now stock vinyl alongside the coffee; films revive the television series of their audiences' childhoods; and a whole industry of 'retro' design promises to return us, for the price of a kettle, to a kitchen we may never actually have had. Hale is good on the commercial uses of longing, and she is wittily unsentimental about them: 'Nostalgia,' she observes, 'is the only form of time travel that comes with a receipt.'
But the book's ambitions are larger than a catalogue of fashions. Its central claim is that nostalgia is neither the harmless indulgence its defenders suppose nor the dangerous illusion its critics fear, but a tool, and that, like any tool, it can build or break depending on the hand that holds it. Hale draws here on the distinction made by the literary scholar Svetlana Boym between 'restorative' and 'reflective' nostalgia. The restorative kind wants to rebuild the lost home exactly as it was, and is impatient with anyone who points out that it never quite existed. The reflective kind lingers on the longing itself; it knows the past is gone, accepts that memory is selective, and finds in that knowledge a source of irony, tenderness and even humour.
Hale's most persuasive chapters concern the private uses of nostalgia, and here she is able to call on a growing body of psychological research. Contrary to the old medical view, a number of studies have suggested that remembering the past fondly can, for many people, lift mood, strengthen a sense of connection to others and help them feel that their lives have meaning and continuity. Nostalgia, on this account, is not a retreat from the present but a resource for coping with it: the student who rereads old messages from home during a lonely first term, or the newly retired teacher who looks through photographs of former classes, may be steadying themselves rather than wallowing. Hale is careful not to overstate the findings, which come mostly from short-term studies, but the picture they paint is a good deal kinder than Hofer's.
The public uses of nostalgia are more contested, and the book handles them with admirable even-handedness. Appeals to a better yesterday are found across the political spectrum and in every period; one generation's golden age is the next generation's cautionary tale. Hale gives a fair hearing to those who argue that such appeals can express real losses, of community, of craft, of familiar landscapes, which deserve to be taken seriously rather than mocked. She also gives space to those who warn that a burnished past can be used to make present difficulties seem simpler than they are, and to forget who was left out of the picture. She does not pretend to settle the argument, and readers hoping for a verdict will be disappointed.
That reluctance is both the book's virtue and its occasional weakness. In the later chapters the careful balancing of views begins to feel like a way of avoiding difficult conclusions, and one longs, ironically enough, for a little of the confidence of the old doctors. The prose, generally lucid, sometimes slips into academic jargon that a stricter editor would have trimmed. And the chapter on social media, though full of sharp observations about the way apps resurface our photographs on anniversaries, will surely date faster than the rest.
These are minor complaints about a humane and illuminating book. Its lasting achievement is to rescue nostalgia from both its admirers and its detractors, and to return it to us as something more interesting than either: an ordinary human capacity, as capable of wisdom as of folly. Hale ends with a sentence that might serve as the book's motto: 'We cannot go home again, but we can go home differently.' It is the kind of line that, years from now, readers may remember with a certain fondness, which is perhaps exactly the point.