Eenglish-tests.com

C2 Text 27 · Debate · 789 words

The Ethics of De-extinction

An edited record of a public symposium in which a geneticist, a philosopher and a conservationist argue about whether we should try to bring back extinct animals.

Few ideas in modern biology are as seductive as bringing back the animals we have lost. Advances in reading and editing genomes have turned what was once science fiction into a set of serious, if distant, research programmes. What follows is an edited record of a public symposium held at a natural history museum in Bristol, chaired by the science writer Ruth Ellison. Her guests were the geneticist Dr Tomás Ferreira, the environmental philosopher Professor Anna Lindqvist and Kwame Asante, who manages habitat restoration for a wildlife charity.

Ruth: Let's begin with a definition. Tomás, when people talk about 'de-extinction', what are they actually proposing? Tomás: Something more modest than the headlines suggest. Nobody can resurrect a woolly mammoth. Ancient DNA is broken into tiny fragments, and even a perfect genome wouldn't give you a mammoth's upbringing, its herd or its world. What we might do is edit the genome of a living relative, in this case the Asian elephant, so that the animal has some mammoth traits: thick hair, extra fat, tolerance of cold. The result would be a proxy, an elephant adapted to the Arctic, not a mammoth brought back from the dead. Ruth: So the name is a little misleading. Tomás: It's marketing, frankly. Useful marketing, but marketing.

Ruth: Anna, you've written that the whole enterprise rests on a category mistake. What do you mean? Anna: A species isn't just a collection of genes. It's a lineage, a history of relationships with particular places and other living things. The last passenger pigeon, Martha, died in Cincinnati Zoo in 1914. Those birds once flew in flocks so vast that they reportedly darkened the sky for hours. If we produce a pigeon with some of their genetic features, we've made something new, perhaps something interesting. But we should be honest that the thread was cut. I worry that the language of 'bringing back' offers a kind of absolution: the comforting sense that extinction is no longer final, so our mistakes are no longer permanent.

Kwame: That's exactly my concern, though I'd put it in practical terms. Conservation is chronically underfunded. Every pound spent on reviving a lost species is a pound not spent protecting the thousands of species that are still here but slipping away. And there's a moral hazard. If developers and governments come to believe that extinction can be reversed, the pressure to prevent it weakens. Tomás: I understand the argument, but it assumes the money comes from the same pot. Much of this research is paid for by private investors who would never give to a wetland project. And the techniques have spin-offs. The same tools could help endangered species that have lost genetic diversity, or protect animals from disease.

Ruth: There's also the question of the animals themselves. In 2003, scientists cloned a Pyrenean ibex, a wild mountain goat that had died out three years earlier. The kid died within minutes of birth. Anna: Which illustrates the welfare problem perfectly. We'd be creating the first members of a social species with no parents of their own kind to learn from. An elephant isn't a machine you simply switch on; much of how it behaves is taught. Whatever we produced would be, in an important sense, an orphan. Tomás: That's a fair point, and it's why any serious project would have to move slowly, with surrogate mothers and long periods of study. I'm not claiming the ethical questions are trivial. I'm claiming they're answerable.

Ruth: Kwame, is there any version of this you could support? Kwame: Possibly, if the starting point were the ecosystem rather than the animal. Large grazing animals shape their landscapes: they trample, they browse, they spread seeds. Some researchers argue that cold-adapted grazers could help keep Arctic grassland from turning to scrub, which might slow the thawing of the frozen soil underneath. I'm sceptical, but it's an argument about ecological function rather than novelty, and that's the right kind of argument to have. Anna: I'd agree with that much. My objection isn't to ambition but to hubris, the belief that our cleverness can undo damage that our cleverness caused.

Ruth: A final word from each of you. Tomás? Tomás: Caution, yes; paralysis, no. Anna: Remember that the most effective de-extinction technology already exists. It's called not letting species die out in the first place. Kwame: And it's considerably cheaper.

The audience vote at the end of the evening was inconclusive: a narrow majority favoured continued research, but almost everyone in the room agreed that the money should not come from existing conservation budgets. It was, Ellison remarked afterwards, an unusually civil disagreement, and perhaps a sign that the real question is not whether we can, but on what terms we should.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
seductive/sɪˈdʌktɪv/very attractive and hard to resist
resurrect/ˌrezəˈrekt/bring back to life
proxy/ˈprɒksi/something that takes the place of another thing
category mistake/ˈkætəɡəri mɪˌsteɪk/an error in which you treat one kind of thing as if it were a different kind
lineage/ˈlɪniɪdʒ/a line of living things that come from the same ancestors
absolution/ˌæbsəˈluːʃən/being freed from guilt or blame
underfunded/ˌʌndəˈfʌndɪd/not given enough money to work properly
moral hazard/ˌmɒrəl ˈhæzəd/a situation in which people take more risks because they think they are protected from the results
spin-offs/ˈspɪnɒfs/useful extra results that come from a project
welfare/ˈwelfeə/health, comfort and happiness
surrogate/ˈsʌrəɡət/taking the place of another; a surrogate mother carries a baby for someone else
browse/braʊz/(of animals) eat leaves and young shoots from bushes and trees
scrub/skrʌb/land covered with small bushes and low trees
sceptical/ˈskeptɪkəl/having doubts; not easily believing that something is true
hubris/ˈhjuːbrɪs/too much pride and confidence in yourself
paralysis/pəˈræləsɪs/a state in which you are unable to act or move
inconclusive/ˌɪnkənˈkluːsɪv/not giving a clear result or answer
civil/ˈsɪvəl/polite and respectful

The Ethics of De-extinction: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.