Eenglish-tests.com

C1 Text 54 · Article · 579 words

Who Owns Culture?

An article weighing up debates about museum collections, cultural borrowing and copyright, and asking who culture really belongs to.

When a museum displays an ancient statue, a fashion brand borrows a traditional pattern or a pop star samples a song from decades ago, a deceptively simple question arises: who does culture belong to? The answer matters, because it touches on history, money, identity and respect, and thoughtful people disagree about it sharply.

Some of the most heated debates concern museums. Many great collections in Europe and North America contain objects that were acquired during periods of empire, sometimes through purchase, sometimes as gifts and sometimes by force. Campaigners argue that items taken in such circumstances should be returned to the communities or countries they came from, and in recent years a number of museums have done exactly that, handing back objects such as some of the Benin Bronzes to Nigeria. Other long-running disputes continue: Greece, for instance, has long asked for the return of the Parthenon Sculptures, which are held in the British Museum in London.

Those who favour keeping such collections together make several arguments. Large international museums, they say, allow millions of visitors to see objects from many civilisations side by side, encouraging comparison and understanding. Some also raise practical concerns about whether objects will be safely looked after, although critics point out that this argument can sound patronising. Increasingly, the debate is moving away from a simple choice between keeping and returning, towards long-term loans, shared research and partnerships between institutions.

A second debate concerns what is often called cultural appropriation: the adoption of elements of one culture by members of another, particularly when the borrowing culture is more powerful. Critics argue that when a global company sells clothes featuring sacred or traditional designs without permission, credit or payment, it profits from a heritage it does not understand, while the original makers may receive nothing. Defenders of cultural exchange reply that cultures have always borrowed from one another, and that much of what we love most, from food to music, is the result of such mixing. Drawing a strict line, they warn, risks treating cultures as fixed and isolated, which they have never been.

Between these positions lies a growing consensus that the key questions are about respect and reciprocity. Has the source been acknowledged? Were the communities involved consulted, and do they benefit? Is something deeply meaningful being treated as a mere costume? 'Borrowing isn't the problem,' says Amara Okoye, a textile designer in Manchester who works closely with weavers in West Africa. 'Taking without asking, without credit and without sharing the rewards: that's the problem.'

The law offers only partial answers. Copyright protects an individual creator's work for a limited period, in the UK and many other countries until seventy years after the creator's death, after which the work enters the public domain and can be freely used. Yet traditional songs, stories and patterns developed by whole communities over centuries rarely fit this model, since they have no single author. International organisations have spent many years discussing how such traditional knowledge might be protected, a question that has proved far from easy to answer.

Perhaps the most useful way to think about culture is not as property to be owned, but as a living inheritance to be shared fairly. That does not settle every dispute, but it shifts the emphasis from 'Who has the right to keep this?' to 'How can we treat this, and the people it comes from, with respect?' It is a harder question, and an infinitely more interesting one.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
deceptively/dɪˈseptɪvli/in a way that makes something seem different from how it really is
heated/ˈhiːtɪd/full of strong feelings and anger
acquired/əˈkwaɪəd/got or obtained
long-running/ˌlɒŋ ˈrʌnɪŋ/continuing for a long time
patronising/ˈpætrənaɪzɪŋ/speaking as if you think you are wiser or better than other people
appropriation/əˌprəʊpriˈeɪʃən/taking something that belongs to others and using it as if it were yours
sacred/ˈseɪkrɪd/very important for religious or spiritual reasons
heritage/ˈherɪtɪdʒ/the traditions, art and history passed down in a community
isolated/ˈaɪsəleɪtɪd/separate, with no contact with others
consensus/kənˈsensəs/general agreement among many people
reciprocity/ˌresɪˈprɒsəti/a fair exchange in which both sides give and receive
acknowledged/əkˈnɒlɪdʒd/recognised and given credit
consulted/kənˈsʌltɪd/asked for their opinion or advice
mere/mɪə/only; nothing more important than
public domain/ˌpʌblɪk dəʊˈmeɪn/the state of belonging to everyone, so anyone can use it freely
inheritance/ɪnˈherɪtəns/something passed down to you from earlier generations

Who Owns Culture?: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.