In an age when anyone with a phone can post a review, what is the point of the professional critic? We put the question to Rosalind Hart, who has reviewed theatre and books for a national newspaper for more than twenty years, and who spends every August watching up to five shows a day at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe.
Interviewer: Let's start with the obvious question. Online reviews are everywhere. Do we still need critics? Rosalind: I'd be lying if I said I hadn't asked myself the same thing. Customer reviews are genuinely useful for some things: whether a restaurant is noisy, whether a hotel is clean. But a piece of art isn't a toaster. A good critic doesn't just tell you whether to buy a ticket. They try to explain what a work is attempting, how it fits into a wider tradition, and whether it succeeds on its own terms. That takes knowledge built up over years and, frankly, the time to think.
Interviewer: Isn't that rather elitist? Who decides that your opinion matters more than mine? Rosalind: It's a fair challenge. As an opinion, mine doesn't matter more than yours. What I'm offering is an argument. If I simply say 'I loved it', that's worthless to a reader. If I explain why, for example the way the lighting changed as the main character lost hope, or the moment the dialogue started to feel false, then you can disagree with me intelligently. The best reviews are conversations, not verdicts.
Interviewer: Have you ever been badly wrong? Rosalind: Oh, many times. Early in my career I gave a lukewarm review to a play that went on to become something of a modern classic. I reread that review every few years as a lesson in humility. Critics have a long history of dismissing work that later turned out to be important. Plenty of novels and paintings that are celebrated today were panned when they first appeared. That should make all of us a little less certain.
Interviewer: How do you balance honesty with kindness, especially with young artists? Rosalind: That's the hardest part of the job. I won't pretend a show is good when it isn't, because readers trust me to be straight with them. But there's a difference between being honest and being cruel. A scathing review might be entertaining to write, yet if a small student company has clearly worked hard, I'd rather point out what didn't work and what showed promise. Ridiculing people for a cheap laugh isn't criticism; it's showing off.
Interviewer: And star ratings? Many readers only look at the stars. Rosalind: I have a love-hate relationship with them. They're convenient, but they flatten everything. A brave, flawed experiment and a perfectly polished but forgettable comedy might both get three stars, and that tells you almost nothing. I always hope people will read the words underneath.
Interviewer: Finally, what would you say to a teenager who wants to become a critic? Rosalind: Read and watch as widely as you can, especially things you think you won't like. Write regularly, even if it's only for a blog or a school magazine. And remember that the job isn't to be clever at the artist's expense. It's to help people see more, feel more and think more. If you can do that, there will always be a place for you, whatever happens to newspapers.