This is an edited transcript of 'Curious Minds', a weekly science podcast. In this episode, the presenter, Tom Ashby, talks to Dr Grace Adeyemi, a neuroscientist at a university in Bristol who studies how the digestive system and the brain communicate.
Tom: We all know the feeling of butterflies in the stomach before an exam. Is that just a figure of speech, or is something real going on? Grace: Oh, it's very real. The gut and the brain are in constant two-way conversation. Researchers call it the gut–brain axis. When you're anxious, your brain sends signals that can change how your gut moves and even how much blood flows to it. That's one reason why stress can affect your appetite or upset your stomach.
Tom: And the conversation goes the other way too? Grace: That's the part that has really surprised scientists. The gut has its own network of nerve cells, hundreds of millions of them, lining the digestive tract. It's sometimes called the 'second brain', although I'd argue that's a slight exaggeration. It can't write poetry or solve equations! But it does control digestion largely by itself, and it constantly reports back to the brain, much of it through a long nerve called the vagus nerve. In fact, most of the traffic along that nerve travels upwards, from the gut to the brain, not the other way.
Tom: Where do the famous gut bacteria come in? Grace: Your intestines are home to trillions of microbes, mainly bacteria but also fungi and viruses, known collectively as the microbiome. They help to break down food we can't digest ourselves, and in the process they produce all sorts of chemicals. Some of these appear to influence the immune system and the nerves of the gut, which may in turn affect the brain. Interestingly, much of the body's serotonin, a chemical linked to mood, is made in the gut, although that serotonin doesn't travel directly to the brain.
Tom: So could the bacteria in my stomach be affecting my mood right now? Grace: That's the million-dollar question, and I have to be careful here. Some of the most striking evidence comes from experiments on mice. Mice raised without any gut bacteria, for instance, behave differently from ordinary mice in tests of stress and social behaviour. In humans, studies have found associations between the make-up of the microbiome and conditions such as depression. But an association isn't the same as a cause. People who are unwell often eat and sleep differently, and those changes could alter their gut bacteria rather than the other way round.
Tom: What about the yoghurts and supplements that claim to boost your mood? Grace: The evidence is mixed, to put it diplomatically. A few small trials have been encouraging, but results vary a great deal, and different products contain different strains of bacteria. I'd be wary of any product promising to transform your mental health. If someone is struggling with their mood or their digestion, the best first step is to talk to a doctor.
Tom: Is there anything we can say with confidence? Grace: Studies suggest that diets rich in fibre are linked to a more diverse microbiome, but we're still working out exactly what that means for the brain. For me, the most exciting thing is the change in perspective. For a long time, we treated the brain as if it were in charge of a passive body. Now we're realising that the relationship is much more of a partnership. We've only begun to understand it, and that's what makes the field so compelling.