Eenglish-tests.com

C1 Real life 1 · Article

Is the four-day week worth it?

A newspaper columnist weighs up the arguments for a shorter working week.

The Northern Chronicle — Opinion

A shorter week will not fix a badly designed one

The four-day week is fashionable, but we risk treating a symptom rather than the illness, argues Helen Marsh.

Helen Marsh

Few workplace ideas have travelled as fast as the four-day week. The trials published so far are encouraging: staff report less stress, managers report steady output, and almost no company that took part wants to go back. I have no wish to pour cold water on any of that.

Yet the enthusiasm deserves some scrutiny. Most of the firms that volunteered were small, office-based and already well run. A business that chooses to experiment is, almost by definition, one that trusts its staff. It would be surprising if such companies did badly.

The harder question is what happens in hospitals, schools and care homes, where work cannot simply be squeezed into fewer days. There, a shorter week means hiring more people, and the money has to come from somewhere. To present the idea as cost-free is, at best, disingenuous.

My real worry, however, is different. Many of the gains in the trials came not from the extra day off but from cutting pointless meetings and endless email chains. In other words, people were finally allowed to work properly. Those changes are worth having on their own, and they do not require a wholesale change to the calendar.

So by all means let us keep experimenting. But if a company can only become efficient under the pressure of losing a day, it was never really short of time. It was short of good management.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
scrutiny/ˈskruːtɪni/careful and critical examination
disingenuous/ˌdɪsɪnˈdʒenjuəs/not completely honest, often pretending to know less than you do
wholesale/ˈhəʊlseɪl/complete and affecting everything

Questions

Question 1 of 70 points

Choose the correct answer

What is the writer's overall position on the four-day week?

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.