On a wet Tuesday morning, the galleries of the Calder Museum in Halifax are almost empty. Online, however, the same collection is busy. A schoolgirl in Kenya is zooming in on the brushstrokes of a Victorian landscape, a retired engineer in Canada is studying a medieval coin, and a student in Wales is downloading an image for her art project. For many institutions, this split between the physical and the digital visitor has become one of the defining questions of the age: what is a museum for when its treasures can be seen from anywhere?
The process behind this shift is known as digitisation: photographing, scanning and cataloguing objects so that they can be found and viewed online. It is slower and more expensive than outsiders tend to assume. Every item must be handled carefully, photographed under controlled lighting and described accurately, and large national collections contain millions of objects. Even so, many museums have now made substantial parts of their collections available, often free of charge. Advanced techniques go further still: 3D scanning allows fragile objects to be examined from every angle without being touched, and special imaging can reveal earlier sketches hidden beneath the surface of a painting.
The benefits are considerable. Researchers no longer need to travel across the world to inspect a single manuscript, and people who cannot easily visit, because of distance, cost or disability, gain access to material that was previously out of reach. When museums around the world had to close their doors during the COVID-19 pandemic, online tours and digital collections became, for a time, the only way to visit at all. Many institutions that had treated their websites as an afterthought discovered that digital audiences were not a sideshow but a central part of their mission.
Not everyone is entirely comfortable with the change. Dr Helen Achterberg, a curator at the Calder Museum, believes something essential is lost on a screen. ‘A digital image is wonderful for study, but it flattens everything,’ she says. ‘You don’t sense the scale of a tapestry, or the way light falls across a sculpture as you walk around it. Standing in front of an object that someone made by hand centuries ago is a different experience altogether.’ Her view echoes an argument made in the 1930s by the German critic Walter Benjamin, who suggested that a reproduction, however perfect, lacks the ‘aura’ of the original: its unique presence in a particular time and place.
Her colleague Sam Whitlow, who manages the museum’s digital programme, takes a more optimistic view. ‘People used to fear that putting collections online would empty the galleries,’ he says. ‘In our experience, the opposite often happens. Someone discovers an object online, becomes curious and then makes the journey to see it in person. The website isn’t a substitute for a visit; it’s an invitation.’ Whitlow also points out that digital tools allow the public to contribute, for instance by helping to transcribe handwritten letters or identify people in old photographs, turning passive viewers into collaborators.
Challenges remain. Digital files must be stored, updated and protected as technology changes, a task that requires long-term funding that museums do not always have. There are also difficult questions about objects taken from other countries in colonial times; for some communities, seeing their heritage digitised by the institution that holds it is no substitute for having it returned. Most experts now agree, however, that the choice is not between the physical and the digital museum. The most forward-looking institutions are treating the two as complementary, each doing what the other cannot. The galleries in Halifax may be quiet this morning, but the museum itself has rarely been busier.