Eenglish-tests.com

C1 Text 90 · Essay · 657 words

How Maps Shaped the World

An essay on how maps, from Ptolemy to smartphones, have always reflected choices and shaped the way people see the world.

We tend to think of a map as a neutral picture of reality, a simple record of where things are. In fact, every map is a series of choices: what to include, what to leave out, what to place at the centre and how to flatten a round planet onto a flat surface. Those choices reflect the knowledge, beliefs and purposes of the people who made them, and maps, in turn, have shaped how whole societies see the world.

One of the most influential mapmakers of all left no map that survives in its original form. In the second century AD, the Greek scholar Ptolemy, working in Alexandria, wrote his Geography, which listed thousands of places with coordinates similar to our latitude and longitude. When the work was translated into Latin in the early fifteenth century, it inspired a new generation of European cartographers, even though its estimate of the size of the Earth was too small. Errors of this kind encouraged Christopher Columbus to believe that Asia lay within reach if he sailed west.

Medieval maps often had quite different aims. The Hereford Mappa Mundi, made around 1300 and still on display in Hereford Cathedral, places Jerusalem at its centre and east at the top. It includes scenes from the Bible, legendary creatures and famous cities alongside rivers and coastlines. To judge it purely on geographical accuracy would be to miss the point: it was designed to show the history and meaning of the world as its makers understood them, not to help anyone find their way. Meanwhile, in 1154, the scholar al-Idrisi completed a remarkably detailed map of the known world for King Roger II of Sicily, drawing on the reports of travellers and merchants. Like many maps made in the Islamic world, it placed south at the top, a reminder that 'north is up' is a convention, not a law of nature.

The map that has arguably done most to shape modern perceptions was published in 1569 by the Flemish cartographer Gerardus Mercator. His projection had a great advantage for navigation: a straight line drawn on it matches a constant compass bearing, so sailors could plan a course with a ruler. The price of this was distortion. On a Mercator map, land near the poles appears far larger than it really is, so Greenland looks roughly the same size as Africa, although Africa is about fourteen times bigger. Because the projection became the standard for school wall maps for generations, critics argue that it quietly exaggerated the importance of Europe and North America. In the 1970s, the German historian Arno Peters promoted an alternative that showed areas correctly but distorted shapes instead. The debate that followed made one thing clear: no flat map can be perfectly accurate, so every projection involves a compromise.

Maps have also been instruments of governance. The Ordnance Survey, founded in 1791, began with military aims at a time when Britain's south coast was seen as vulnerable to invasion, but it went on to produce detailed maps of the whole country that walkers still use today. Maps have even helped to save lives. In 1854, during an outbreak of cholera in Soho, London, the doctor John Snow recorded where cases had occurred on a street map. The cluster of cases around a water pump in Broad Street supported his argument that the disease was spread by contaminated water rather than bad air: a landmark moment in public health.

Today, most of us carry a map in our pockets that updates itself in real time. Digital mapping has made navigation almost effortless and has allowed communities to map places that official maps once ignored. Yet the old questions have not disappeared. Someone still decides what appears on the screen, which businesses are shown first and which routes we are offered. Maps, in other words, remain what they have always been: not simply mirrors of the world, but powerful arguments about it.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
neutral/ˈnjuːtrəl/not supporting any side or showing any particular opinion
coordinates/kəʊˈɔːdɪnəts/a pair of numbers that show the exact position of a place
cartographers/kɑːˈtɒɡrəfəz/people who make maps
within reach/wɪðɪn ˈriːtʃ/close enough to get to
convention/kənˈvenʃən/a usual way of doing something that most people accept
arguably/ˈɑːɡjuəbli/used to say that something may be true, although not everyone may agree
perceptions/pəˈsepʃənz/the ways in which people see and understand something
projection/prəˈdʒekʃən/a way of showing the round Earth on a flat map
compass bearing/ˈkʌmpəs ˌbeərɪŋ/a direction measured with a compass, such as north-east
distortion/dɪˈstɔːʃən/a change that makes something look different from how it really is
compromise/ˈkɒmprəmaɪz/a solution in which you accept some disadvantages to get some advantages
governance/ˈɡʌvənəns/the way a country or organisation is controlled and managed
vulnerable/ˈvʌlnərəbəl/easy to attack or hurt
cluster/ˈklʌstə/a group of things close together
contaminated/kənˈtæmɪneɪtɪd/made dirty or harmful by something such as germs
landmark/ˈlændmɑːk/very important, marking a big change or new stage

How Maps Shaped the World: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.