Eenglish-tests.com

B2 Text 15 · Opinion · 481 words

Who Should Pay for University?

A sixth-form student in Leicester looks at both sides of the debate about whether students or everyone through taxes should pay for university.

This year, many of my friends in the sixth form in Leicester are filling in university applications. Alongside the excitement, one question comes up again and again: how are we going to pay for it? Governments around the world answer this question in very different ways, and it leads to one of the liveliest debates in education. Should university be free for students, paid for by everyone through taxes? Or should the people who get a degree pay for it themselves?

Different countries have chosen different paths. In some European countries, such as Germany, public universities charge local students very low fees or none at all. In England, by contrast, most students pay tuition fees, but they usually take out a government loan to cover them. They only start paying it back once they are earning above a certain amount, and the payments depend on their income. Even within the UK, the systems differ: most Scottish students who study in Scotland do not pay tuition fees.

Those who believe university should be free argue that education is a public good, not just a private one. Society needs doctors, engineers, nurses and teachers, and everyone benefits when people are well educated. They also worry that fees put off young people from poorer families, who may be afraid of starting their adult lives in debt. If talented students choose not to apply because of money, they say, the whole country loses out.

On the other side, many people believe it is fairer for students to contribute. On average, graduates tend to earn more over their lifetimes than people without a degree, so why should someone who left school at sixteen and works in a shop help to pay for a future lawyer's education? Supporters of fees also point out that free systems can be very expensive for governments. When money is limited, universities may have fewer places, larger classes or less modern equipment, which could harm the quality of teaching.

Of course, the debate isn't simply black and white. Many people support a compromise: students pay something, but only when they can afford it, and extra help such as grants goes to those who need it most. Others suggest that employers, who benefit from hiring skilled graduates, should chip in too. And some point out that university is not the only route to a good career: apprenticeships, where young people earn money while they train, deserve more attention.

Having looked at both sides, I can understand why reasonable people disagree. Personally, I believe that nobody should be prevented from going to university because of their family's income, but I also think it's fair for graduates who do well to give something back. Whatever system a country chooses, the most important thing is that young people can make their choice based on their interests and abilities, not their bank balance. What do you think?

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
taxes/ˈtæksɪz/money that people and companies must pay to the government to pay for public services
tuition fees/tjuˈɪʃən fiːz/the money you pay to a college or university for teaching
loan/ləʊn/money that someone lends you and that you must pay back later
public good/ˌpʌblɪk ˈɡʊd/something that is useful for everyone in society, not just for one person
put off/ˌpʊt ˈɒf/to make someone not want to do something
in debt/ɪn ˈdet/owing money to someone
loses out/ˌluːzɪz ˈaʊt/does not get an advantage or benefit that it could have had
contribute/kənˈtrɪbjuːt/to give part of the money or help needed for something
black and white/ˌblæk ən ˈwaɪt/with only two simple sides, one right and one wrong
compromise/ˈkɒmprəmaɪz/an agreement in which each side accepts part of what the other side wants
grants/ɡrɑːnts/money given for studying that you don't have to pay back
chip in/ˌtʃɪp ˈɪn/to give some money together with other people
apprenticeships/əˈprentɪsʃɪps/jobs where young people learn a skill at work while they are paid
bank balance/ˈbæŋk ˌbæləns/the amount of money you have in the bank

Who Should Pay for University?: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.