An internship is a period of work experience, usually for students or recent graduates, that can last from a few weeks to several months. Some internships are paid, but others offer no salary at all. Are unpaid internships a useful stepping stone or an unfair system? This week, two readers share their views.
Oliver Grant, 23, from Norwich, says they can be worth it: 'Two summers ago, I spent four weeks as an unpaid intern at a small film company. I made tea, answered phones and, yes, did a lot of photocopying. But I also watched professionals at work, asked endless questions and was eventually allowed to help on a real shoot. That experience gave me something no university course could: contacts. When a paid job came up at the same company six months later, they thought of me first. In competitive industries, it can be incredibly hard to get a foot in the door. A short unpaid placement shows employers that you are committed and willing to learn. Of course, it shouldn't go on for ever, but a few weeks of free work was a price worth paying for my career.'
Megan Lloyd, 21, from Cardiff, disagrees: 'I understand why Oliver is grateful, but his story hides a bigger problem. Last year I was offered an unpaid internship at a magazine in London, and I had to turn it down. Living in London for three months without a salary would have cost far more than my family could afford. The person who took the place instead could probably manage because their parents helped them. Unpaid internships mean that the best opportunities often go to people from well-off backgrounds, not necessarily to the most talented. That isn't fair, and it isn't good for the industries either, because they end up hearing from a narrower range of voices. If interns are doing real work that benefits a company, they should be paid for it. In the UK, the law already says that interns who count as workers should usually receive at least the minimum wage, but not everyone knows their rights.'
So who is right? Perhaps both of them. Many people agree that short periods of shadowing, where a student simply watches and learns, are different from long placements where interns do the same work as paid staff. Some companies now offer paid internships, or bursaries to help with travel and living costs, so that a wider range of young people can apply. What do you think? Should experience ever be a substitute for pay?