Eenglish-tests.com

B2 Text 17 · Article · 468 words

Teaching Critical Thinking

An article about a school in York that teaches students to question what they read online, and about the arguments for and against such lessons.

A Year 9 class in York is looking at a viral post which claims that a common garden bird has disappeared from Britain. Within minutes, hands go up. 'Who wrote it?' asks one student. 'Where's the evidence?' asks another. 'Why would someone want us to believe this?' This is a typical 'Think Again' lesson, a weekly class that the school introduced three years ago to teach students how to evaluate what they read, hear and watch.

Their teacher, Claire Lowe, explains why she believes the lessons matter. 'Young people today have more information at their fingertips than any generation before them,' she says. 'The problem isn't finding information; it's knowing what to trust. A convincing video or a confident headline isn't the same as evidence.'

One technique the students learn is sometimes called 'lateral reading'. Instead of staying on a website and judging it by how professional it looks, they open new tabs and find out what other, reliable sources say about it. They also practise separating facts, which can be checked, from opinions, which can't, and they learn to spot bias – when a writer presents only one side of a story. 'At first, many of them take things at face value,' says Ms Lowe. 'By the end of the year, they automatically ask who is behind a message and what they might gain from it.'

Not everyone is convinced that critical thinking should be taught as a separate subject, however. Some educational researchers argue that it cannot really be taught on its own, because good thinking depends on knowledge. A student who knows a lot about history, they point out, is far better at questioning a historical claim than one who has simply learnt a checklist. From this point of view, the best way to develop critical thinkers is to give them a rich, well-rounded education in every subject.

Others worry about a different danger: that students might swing from believing everything to believing nothing. If young people are told again and again that information can't be trusted, they may become cynical and dismiss even solid scientific evidence as 'just another opinion'.

Ms Lowe takes these criticisms seriously. 'They're fair points,' she admits. 'That's why we work closely with other departments. In science, students look at how experiments are designed; in history, they compare different sources. And we're very clear that the goal isn't to doubt everything. It's to ask good questions and then weigh up the answers. Some sources really are more trustworthy than others, and recognising that is part of thinking critically.'

Her students seem to agree. 'It's made me slow down,' says fourteen-year-old Amira. 'Before, I'd share things straight away. Now I check first – and last week I even helped my gran check a story before she shared it with her friends.'

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
viral/ˈvaɪərəl/shared very quickly by a very large number of people online
evaluate/ɪˈvæljueɪt/think carefully about how good, true or useful something is
at their fingertips/ət ðeə ˈfɪŋɡətɪps/very easy for them to get and use
convincing/kənˈvɪnsɪŋ/making you believe that something is true
reliable/rɪˈlaɪəbəl/that you can trust
bias/ˈbaɪəs/an unfair way of showing only one side or favouring one opinion
take things at face value/ˌteɪk ˈθɪŋz ət ˌfeɪs ˈvæljuː/believe what you see or hear without asking any questions
well-rounded/ˌwel ˈraʊndɪd/broad and varied, covering many different areas
swing/swɪŋ/change suddenly from one extreme to the opposite one
cynical/ˈsɪnɪkəl/believing that nothing and nobody can be trusted
dismiss/dɪˈsmɪs/refuse to think about something seriously
admits/ədˈmɪts/agrees that something is true, often when it is not easy to say
weigh up/ˌweɪ ˈʌp/think carefully about the good and bad sides of something before deciding

Teaching Critical Thinking: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.