This is part of a debate held at a science festival in Edinburgh. The presenter, Laura Bennett, spoke to Sam Patel, a software engineer who works on self-driving technology, and Gareth Hughes, a driving instructor from Swansea with thirty years' experience.
Laura: Sam, let's start with you. How does a car drive itself? Sam: It uses a combination of cameras, radar and other sensors to build a picture of everything around it: other vehicles, cyclists, traffic lights, road markings. Powerful software then decides how to steer, speed up or brake, many times every second. Laura: And why should we want one? Sam: Mainly safety. The vast majority of road accidents involve human error: drivers who are tired, distracted or going too fast. A computer never checks its phone and never gets sleepy. I also think about people who can't drive at the moment, such as many elderly or disabled people. A self-driving car could give them back their independence.
Laura: Gareth, you look sceptical. Gareth: I am, a little. Sam's right that people make mistakes, and I see plenty of them in my job! But driving isn't just following rules. It's about reading situations. A ball rolls into the road, and you know a child might run after it. A police officer waves you through a red light. Snow covers the lines on the road. Humans cope with these unpredictable moments surprisingly well. Sam: That's a fair point, and it's exactly what engineers are working on. The cars learn from huge amounts of driving, including rare situations. They aren't perfect yet, which is why they're being tested so carefully.
Laura: What about when something does go wrong? Who's to blame? Gareth: That's my biggest worry. If I make a mistake, I'm responsible. If a car makes one, is it the owner, the manufacturer or the person who wrote the software? In many countries, the law is still catching up. Sam: I agree that needs sorting out before the technology becomes common. There are also questions about cyber security, making sure nobody can hack into a car, and engineers take that extremely seriously.
Laura: Gareth, would you ever get into one? Gareth: Honestly? Eventually, yes, once it's been proved safe over many years. I'm not against progress. I just don't think we should rush it. And we mustn't forget the people who drive for a living, like lorry and taxi drivers. Their jobs matter too. Laura: Sam, a final word? Sam: I'd say Gareth and I want the same thing: fewer accidents. The change will be gradual. In the near future, we're more likely to see cars that help drivers, for example by braking automatically, than cars with no steering wheel at all. Trust has to be earned.