This is an edited transcript from Young Voices, a radio programme for students. Presenter Nadia Rahman asks two guests whether Britain can run on renewable energy: Ben Carter, an engineer who works on offshore wind farms, and Helen Moss, who lives in a village in Cumbria and chairs a local community group.
Nadia: Ben, let's start with you. Why are you so optimistic? Ben: Because Britain is in a fantastic position. We're an island surrounded by shallow seas and strong winds, which is ideal for offshore wind. Turbines out at sea can be enormous, and the wind there is stronger and steadier than on land. On top of that, the cost of wind and solar power has fallen sharply in recent years, so clean energy is no longer a luxury.
Nadia: Helen, do you share his enthusiasm? Helen: Up to a point. I'm all for clean energy – I've got solar panels on my own roof. But I think we sometimes rush into big projects without listening to the people who live nearby. A company wanted to build a solar farm on fields near our village, and lots of my neighbours felt that nobody had asked them. Nadia: So for you it's about how it's done, not whether it's done? Helen: Exactly. When people feel left out, they push back. Ben: That's fair. The industry hasn't always been good at explaining itself.
Nadia: What about the obvious problem? The wind doesn't always blow, and the sun doesn't always shine. Ben: That's the big challenge – engineers call it intermittency. But there are answers. Batteries can store surplus electricity on windy days. Another option is pumped hydro: you pump water uphill when power is cheap and let it flow back down through turbines when you need it. We're also linked to neighbouring countries by undersea cables, so we can share power. And the sources work well together: wind is often strongest in winter, while solar does best in summer.
Helen: I'd add that the cleanest energy is the energy we don't use at all. Many British homes are old and draughty. In our village, volunteers have helped families insulate their lofts, and people have noticed the difference in their bills straight away.
Nadia: Helen, is there anything that would win over your neighbours? Helen: Community energy. In some places, villagers own a wind turbine or a solar scheme together, and the profits go back into the community – a new roof for the village hall, say. When people have a stake in a project, their attitudes can change completely. Ben: I agree. And let's not forget the sea itself. Britain has some of the strongest tides in Europe, and tidal power could become important, although the technology is still developing.
Nadia: We're almost out of time. Final thoughts? Ben: The technology is ready. Now we need to build faster. Helen: Build, yes – but build together. Bring people on board, and the rest will follow.