Exeter City Council is considering a plan to close several streets in the city centre to most cars from next spring. Last Thursday, a panel discussion about the plan was held at the city library. It was chaired by Rachel Moore, the editor of a local newspaper. Here is part of it.
Rachel: Welcome, everyone. Councillor Sharma, could you briefly explain the plan? Dev Sharma: Of course. We're proposing to make four streets around the cathedral car-free between 10 a.m. and 6 p.m. Buses, taxis and bikes would still be allowed, and so would delivery vans before ten. Our aim is cleaner air, safer streets and more space for people to walk, sit and meet.
Rachel: Linda, you run a shoe shop on one of those streets. How do you feel? Linda Price: Worried, to be frank. My family has had the shop for forty years, and many of our older customers drive in from villages where buses are rare. If they can't park nearby, I'm afraid they'll simply shop online instead. I'm not opposed to change, but small businesses are already struggling, and this could be the last straw. Dev Sharma: I completely understand that concern. However, studies in several European cities have shown that when streets become pedestrian-friendly, people tend to stay longer and spend more.
Rachel: Oliver, you represent a local cycling group. Oliver Grant: Yes, and I'm also a dad of two. At the moment, I wouldn't let my children cycle into town because the traffic is just too heavy. A car-free centre would give families the confidence to leave the car at home. I'd go further, actually: I'd make the scheme permanent and all-day.
Rachel: Margaret, you work for a charity that supports disabled people. Margaret Hall: Thank you. We welcome cleaner air, but we must make sure nobody is left behind. For some people, a car isn't a luxury; it's the only way they can get around. So we're asking for blue-badge parking at the edge of the zone and a free electric shuttle. Dev Sharma: That's a very reasonable request, and I'll take it back to the council.
Rachel: Let's take a question from the audience. Yes, the young man at the back? Tom: Hi, I'm Tom and I'm fourteen. Could the council try it for a few months first, before deciding? Rachel: Good idea! Linda? Linda Price: Actually, I'd be much happier with a trial. If my takings fall, at least we'd know, and the plan could be changed. Dev Sharma: That's something we're seriously considering, perhaps a six-month trial with a review at the end. Rachel: Thank you all. Residents can comment on the plan on the council's website until the end of the month.