Eenglish-tests.com

B2 Text 51 · Article · 515 words

How Clever Are Animals?

From tool-making crows to dancing bees, an article about what scientists have discovered about animal intelligence, and why the question is harder than it seems.

For centuries, many people believed that humans were the only truly intelligent creatures on Earth. Animals, it was said, simply followed their instincts: they built nests, hunted and found their way home without really thinking about what they were doing. Over the last fifty years, however, scientists have come up with clever experiments that have changed this picture dramatically.

Take tool use, which was once seen as a sign of human intelligence. Chimpanzees strip the leaves off thin sticks and push them into termite nests, then pull them out covered in insects to eat. Even more surprising are New Caledonian crows, which bend twigs and cut leaves into hooks to fish insects out of holes in trees. In laboratory tests, some of these crows have solved puzzles that need several steps to be carried out in the right order.

Memory is another area where animals can outperform us. A grey squirrel may bury thousands of nuts in autumn and still find many of them months later. Some members of the crow family go further. If a jay notices that another bird is watching while it hides food, it often returns later and moves the food to a new place, as if it understands that the other bird might steal it.

Scientists have also asked whether animals are self-aware. In the famous mirror test, a coloured mark is placed on an animal's body where it can only be seen in a mirror. If the animal looks in the mirror and then touches the mark on its own body, it seems to recognise itself. Great apes, dolphins, elephants and magpies have passed the test in some studies. Dogs usually fail, but critics point out that dogs explore the world mainly through smell, so a test based on sight may be unfair to them.

Communication can be remarkably complex, too. When a honeybee finds a good patch of flowers, it returns to the hive and performs a 'waggle dance' that tells other bees in which direction to fly and roughly how far. Octopuses, meanwhile, can open jars, escape from tanks and recognise individual people, even though their brains are built in a completely different way from ours.

So which animal is the cleverest? Dr Hannah Price, who studies animal behaviour at a university in Bristol, thinks the question itself is misleading. 'Asking whether a crow is cleverer than a dog is a bit like asking whether a hammer is better than a saw,' she says. 'Each species is clever in the ways that matter for its own life.' She also warns against jumping to conclusions. 'When a dog looks guilty, we assume it feels sorry. In fact, it may simply be reacting to our angry voice.'

These discoveries matter beyond the laboratory. The more we learn about the minds of other creatures, the more questions we have to ask about how we treat them, from farm animals to wildlife in habitats that are under threat. Animals may not think exactly like us, but it is becoming harder and harder to argue that they do not think at all.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
instincts/ˈɪnstɪŋkts/natural ways of behaving that an animal is born with and does not have to learn
come up with/ˌkʌm ˈʌp wɪð/thought of or invented (an idea or a plan)
dramatically/drəˈmætɪkli/very much and in a way that is easy to notice
termite/ˈtɜːmaɪt/a small insect that lives in large groups and builds big nests of earth
outperform/ˌaʊtpəˈfɔːm/do something better than someone else
self-aware/ˌself əˈweə/able to understand that you exist as a separate individual
critics/ˈkrɪtɪks/people who point out problems or weak points in an idea
remarkably/rɪˈmɑːkəbli/in a surprising way that makes people notice
misleading/ˌmɪsˈliːdɪŋ/likely to give people the wrong idea
jumping to conclusions/ˌdʒʌmpɪŋ tə kənˈkluːʒnz/deciding something too quickly, before you know all the facts
habitats/ˈhæbɪtæts/the natural places where particular animals or plants live
argue/ˈɑːɡjuː/give reasons to show that something is true

How Clever Are Animals?: tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.