Fiona Grant has come back to Peak and Trail, an outdoor shop in Keswick, with a pair of walking boots. The assistant manager, Kieran Walsh, comes to the counter to help.
Kieran: Good morning. I'm Kieran, the assistant manager. My colleague said you have a problem with some boots? Fiona: Yes. I bought these here three weeks ago for £120. The label said they were completely waterproof. On Saturday I wore them for the first time on a walk around Derwentwater, and after an hour my socks were soaking. Kieran: Oh dear, I'm sorry to hear that. That's not what should happen with these boots. May I have a look? Fiona: Please do. And to be honest, I'm quite annoyed. I'd told the assistant I was planning a long walking holiday in Scotland, and he assured me these were the best boots for it.
Kieran: I completely understand. Let me check… Yes, I can see the problem. The seam here at the side has come apart. That's a manufacturing fault, not something you've done. Fiona: So I'd like a full refund, please. Kieran: I can certainly arrange that if you prefer. Before you decide, though, may I suggest another option? Your holiday is soon, isn't it? Fiona: In ten days. Kieran: Then a refund might leave you without boots at the worst possible moment. We've had a few problems with this model, so we've stopped selling it. Instead, I could offer you these. They're £150, but you wouldn't pay the difference. They've had excellent reviews, and I wear them myself.
Fiona: Hmm. I'm a little wary after what happened. How do I know these won't leak too? Kieran: That's a reasonable question. They come with a two-year guarantee, and if there's any problem at all, bring them straight back to me personally. You could also wear them around the house for a few days first. If they don't feel right, we'll give you the full refund then, no questions asked. Fiona: That sounds fair. I'll try them on.
A few minutes later… Fiona: They're much more comfortable, actually. The other ones always pinched a bit at the toes. Kieran: That's good to hear. I'd also like to give you a £15 voucher for the inconvenience. It could buy you some proper walking socks for Scotland! Fiona: That's kind of you. I came in ready for an argument, to be honest, but you've really turned things around. Kieran: We'd much rather fix a problem than lose a customer. And I'll speak to the team about checking customers' plans more carefully. Enjoy Scotland, and send us a photo from the top of a mountain if you get the chance. Fiona: I'll do that. Thanks, Kieran.