Every Thursday, the science club at Westfield Academy in Exeter holds a debate. This week's topic is gene editing. Their teacher, Ms Ahmed, begins by explaining the basics.
Ms Ahmed: Every living thing carries instructions in its DNA, a bit like a recipe book, and genes are the individual recipes. For decades, scientists could read these instructions, but changing them was slow and difficult. Then, in 2012, researchers including Jennifer Doudna and Emmanuelle Charpentier described a tool called CRISPR. It works rather like a pair of tiny scissors that can cut DNA at a precise point, so that a gene can be switched off or corrected. In 2020, the two women won the Nobel Prize in Chemistry for their work.
Priya: I think it's one of the most exciting breakthroughs ever. Take sickle cell disease. It's an inherited blood condition that can cause terrible pain. In 2023, the UK became the first country to approve a treatment for it based on CRISPR. For some patients, that could be life-changing. Leo: I agree it sounds amazing, but how do we know it's safe? What if the scissors cut in the wrong place? Mistakes like that could cause new problems that nobody notices for years. Ms Ahmed: That's a real concern, Leo, and it's why new treatments go through years of careful testing before doctors are allowed to use them.
Callum: It's not just about medicine, though. Scientists are also editing crops. Some plants could be made more resistant to disease or better at coping with drought. With the climate changing, that could help farmers feed more people. Grace: But shouldn't we be careful about changing nature? Once an edited plant is growing in fields, it's hard to take it back. I'd want to see a lot of evidence first. Callum: Fair enough, but farmers have been changing plants for thousands of years by choosing the best seeds. Gene editing is just faster and more precise.
Ms Ahmed: There's one question that worries many people most. Most treatments change cells in one patient's body only. But if you edited the DNA of an embryo, the changes would be passed on to future generations. At the moment, most countries do not allow this. Priya: I think that's right, at least for now. We don't understand the long-term effects well enough. Grace: And who decides what counts as an 'improvement'? Curing a serious disease is one thing, but what if rich parents wanted to choose features like height? That could make society even more unequal. Leo: Cost is already a problem. These treatments are incredibly expensive. If only wealthy people can afford them, is that fair?
Ms Ahmed: So, can we reach a conclusion? Callum: I'd say gene editing has huge potential, but it needs clear rules. Grace: And everyone should have a say, not just scientists and companies. Ms Ahmed: I think that's a sensible place to stop. Gene editing isn't simply good or bad. Like many powerful technologies, it raises questions that science alone can't answer. That's why it matters that you, as future voters, understand it.