Every August, Edinburgh is transformed. Jugglers, musicians and comedians fill the streets, and thousands of shows take place in theatres, churches, pubs and even tiny rooms above shops. The Fringe, which began in 1947 when a few theatre companies turned up uninvited at the city's new international festival, is now often described as the largest arts festival in the world. All over the world, from carnivals to music weekends, festivals have become a major tourist attraction.
There is no doubt that festivals can bring real benefits. Visitors spend money in hotels, restaurants and shops, and many local people find extra work. A festival can also put a small place on the map. Take Hollinsby, a market town in North Yorkshire. In 2009, a handful of volunteers organised a lantern parade to brighten up the dark November evenings. Today, around twenty thousand people come to watch. "Those three days help to pay for our quiet winter months," says Ruth Pearson, who runs a café on the main square. Residents, too, enjoy concerts and exhibitions on their doorstep that they would normally have to travel to see.
However, success comes at a price. Overcrowding is the most obvious problem: pavements become packed, buses are full and queues stretch down the street. "I love the festival," says Hollinsby resident Martin Clegg, "but some years I can't even get into my local shop." In bigger cities, prices for food and accommodation can rise sharply, and some flats are turned into holiday lets, which leaves fewer homes for people who live and work there all year. Then there is the litter, the noise and the environmental cost of thousands of people travelling, often by car or plane.
There is also a less visible risk. When a festival grows too fast, local people may feel that it no longer belongs to them. A celebration that once had a real meaning for the community can turn into a show put on mainly for visitors and their cameras.
So what can be done? Some cities now charge visitors a small tourist tax for each night they stay and spend the money on local services, such as cleaning and transport. Others limit the number of holiday lets or spread out events across the year. In Hollinsby, a residents' committee now helps to plan the parade, local families receive free tickets for the best viewing areas, and a park-and-ride bus keeps cars out of the town centre.
Festivals can bring joy, money and fresh ideas, but they work best when visitors and locals are on the same side. The best festivals, it seems, are the ones that remember who they were created for in the first place.