Every month, the debating club at Bryn Hill School in Cardiff chooses a question that divides opinion. This month's motion was 'Everyone who needs a car should switch to an electric one.' Here is part of the debate, chaired by the geography teacher, Mrs Hughes.
Mrs Hughes: Ffion, you're speaking for the motion. Why should drivers switch? Ffion: The most obvious reason is the air we breathe. Electric cars don't have an exhaust, so they don't pump out fumes in our streets. That matters near schools and busy roads, where pollution can harm people's lungs. They're also much quieter, which makes towns more pleasant to live in.
Mrs Hughes: Daniel, you're speaking against. Surely cleaner air is a good thing? Daniel: Of course it is, and I'm not saying electric cars are bad. My point is that 'everyone' is too strong. A new electric car usually costs more to buy than a similar petrol one, and many families simply can't afford that. Also, charging points aren't spread evenly. If you live in a flat without a driveway, or in a remote village, charging can be a real hassle.
Ffion: The price is a fair point, but you have to look at the whole picture. Electric cars are often cheaper to run, especially if you charge at home overnight, and they have fewer moving parts, so there's less to go wrong. Over the years, the savings can make up for the higher price. And more second-hand electric cars are appearing all the time.
Daniel: Maybe, but what about the batteries? They need materials like lithium, which have to be mined, and mining can damage the landscape and use lots of water. Plus, an electric car is only as clean as the electricity it uses. If that electricity comes from burning fossil fuels, the benefit is smaller. Ffion: That's true, but more and more electricity comes from wind and solar power, so electric cars get cleaner as the grid does. Petrol cars, on the other hand, will always burn fuel. Batteries can increasingly be recycled, too.
Mrs Hughes: Let's take one last point each. Daniel: Even electric cars wear down their tyres and brakes, which release tiny particles, and they still get stuck in traffic jams. So I'd argue the real answer is fewer cars, with better buses, trains and cycle lanes. Ffion: I actually agree with that! But for journeys where people genuinely need a car, electric is the better choice for the planet.
When the votes were counted, the motion was narrowly defeated, but almost everyone agreed with the idea that both speakers ended on: the cleanest journey is the one you walk, cycle or share.