Every month, the debating club at Riverside Academy in Leicester holds a debate in front of the whole of Year 9. This month's motion was: "This house would ban homework." Here are the main parts of the debate.
Ms Okafor: Good afternoon, everyone. Each main speaker has three minutes. Leah, you're speaking for the motion, so you begin. Leah: Thank you. Most of us already spend seven hours a day at school. When we get home, we're exhausted, yet we're expected to do another two hours of work. In my opinion, that isn't fair. Young people need time to play sport, see friends, help at home and simply rest. Besides, homework isn't equal. Some students have a quiet room and parents who can help; others share a bedroom with three brothers. Homework widens the gap between them. If we need extra practice, it should happen during the school day.
Ms Okafor: Thank you, Leah. Daniel, you're speaking against the motion. Daniel: Thank you. I agree with Leah that some students have too much homework, but banning it completely would be throwing the baby out with the bathwater. Homework teaches us to organise our time and work independently, and those are skills we'll need at college and at work. It also gives us a chance to practise. You can't learn a language or a musical instrument only in lessons. As for the gap Leah mentioned, the answer is homework clubs, where everyone gets a quiet space and help, not a ban.
Ms Okafor: Now let's hear from the floor. Yes, Ruby? Ruby: I don't completely agree with either speaker. I think the problem isn't homework itself; it's the amount and the kind. Copying out notes for an hour is pointless. But reading a book or researching a topic you're interested in can be really rewarding. So my suggestion is a limit: no more than thirty minutes a night for our age, and it should always have a clear purpose. Ms Okafor: Interesting. Leah, would you accept that? Leah: It's a fair point, and it would certainly be better than what we have now. However, I still believe evenings should belong to families. Daniel: Actually, I'd go along with Ruby's limit. Quality matters more than quantity.
Ms Okafor: Before we vote, Mr Hughes, as head of Year 9, would you like to add anything? Mr Hughes: Only that I've been impressed by how respectfully you've all argued. For what it's worth, the school is reviewing its homework policy this term, so we will genuinely listen to today's result.
Ms Okafor: Right, it's time to vote… The results are: 61 for the motion, 84 against, and 15 abstentions. The motion is defeated, but I think we've all learned something today. Thank you, everyone.