Children today see more adverts than ever before. They appear not only on television but also in games, on video-sharing sites and in apps, sometimes so cleverly mixed with entertainment that it is hard to tell where the fun ends and the selling begins. Should advertising aimed at children be banned? We asked two people with very different views.
Rachel Price, a primary school teacher and mother of two from Norwich, believes a ban is long overdue. 'Young children simply don't understand that an advert is trying to sell them something,' she says. 'Many experts agree that until around the age of eight, children often see adverts as just another kind of programme. That makes it unfair to target them. Adults can resist clever marketing; a six-year-old can't.'
Rachel is particularly concerned about online games. 'Some games are free to download, but then they keep encouraging players to buy extra items. My son once spent his pocket money on a virtual hat without really understanding that it was real money. Children shouldn't be under pressure like that.' She also points out that adverts can make children feel that they need the latest toy or gadget to fit in, which can lead to arguments at home and put a strain on family budgets. 'Some countries, such as Sweden, have banned television adverts aimed at young children for many years. If they can do it, why can't we?'
Daniel Okoro, who lectures in marketing at a college in Leeds, agrees that children need protection, but he thinks a complete ban would be the wrong answer. 'Advertising pays for a lot of the things children enjoy, including free apps and children's television,' he explains. 'Without it, many of those programmes and games would have to charge money, and families who can't afford them would lose out.'
Daniel believes that stricter rules and better education would be more effective. 'In the UK, there are already rules about what can be shown to children, for example limits on adverts for foods high in fat, sugar and salt around children's programmes. I'd like to see clearer rules for games and apps too, so that adverts are always clearly labelled.' He also thinks schools have a role to play. 'If we teach children how adverts work, why the colours are bright, why the music is catchy, why famous faces are used, they become much harder to fool. A ban protects children until a certain age, but media literacy protects them for life.'
Interestingly, the two speakers agree on more than you might expect. Both think that hidden advertising is the biggest problem, and both believe that parents should talk openly with their children about what they see. Where they differ is on the solution: Rachel wants a clear legal ban, while Daniel prefers rules and education. Which approach do you find more convincing?