It's Saturday evening in a flat in Cardiff. Amira, 14, is waiting for her favourite programme, 'Hidden Talents', to start. Her brother Jake, 17, comes into the living room.
Jake: Are you watching that again? I can't believe you waste your Saturday evenings on reality TV. Amira: It's not a waste! This show is different. The contestants are ordinary people – a nurse, a farmer, a teenager from Belfast – and every week they have to learn a new skill, like juggling or ice skating. Jake: But it isn't real, is it? Everything is scripted. The producers tell people what to say.
Amira: Some shows are like that, I agree. But in this one, you can see they're really trying. Last week, a man called Gareth fell over about twenty times while he was learning to skate, and he never gave up. Jake: That's my point. They show people falling over because it's funny. It's entertainment, not real life. I read an article which said that some contestants on reality shows feel terrible afterwards, because millions of people have seen their worst moments.
Amira: That's true, and I think it's unfair when programmes make fun of people. But 'Hidden Talents' is kind. The judges give helpful advice, and nobody gets shouted at. Also, the winner gets £20,000 for a charity of their choice. Jake: OK, that's a nice idea. But wouldn't you rather watch a documentary and learn something? Amira: I do learn things! I've learned how hard it is to play the drums, and I've started practising juggling myself. Anyway, you watch football for three hours every Sunday. Isn't that entertainment too?
Jake: Football is a real sport! Amira: And this is a real competition. The viewers vote for the winner, so it's fair. Jake: Fine. If I watch it with you tonight, will you stop talking about it? Amira: Maybe. Sit down – it's starting!