C2 British · Text 12
The Retreating Coast
Geographer Dr Sarah Bell gives a short lecture on the crumbling cliffs of Happisburgh in Norfolk and the hard question of whether to defend them or let the sea win.
49 sentences · Tap a sentence to hear it again
Text
Good afternoon, everyone. Today I want to take you to a small village on the north-east coast of Norfolk called Happisburgh. Its name looks as though it should be said exactly as it's written, but the locals call it Haze-bruh, and if you remember nothing else from this session, that alone will spare you some puzzled looks if you ever visit. Happisburgh is famous for two things: a red-and-white striped lighthouse, and the fact that it is, quite literally, falling into the sea.
Let's start with why. The cliffs here aren't made of chalk or granite. They're made of sand, gravel and clay left behind by glaciers hundreds of thousands of years ago, and that kind of material is very soft. Waves attack the base of the cliff, rainwater soaks in from the top, and every so often a whole section simply slumps onto the beach. Over the long term the coastline has been moving back by somewhere between one and two metres a year on average. But averages hide a great deal. In a single stormy winter, some stretches have lost as much as ten metres.
For a while, people held the sea back. Wooden barriers were built along the beach in the late 1950s, and for decades they absorbed much of the waves' energy. By the 1990s, though, they were falling apart, and repairing them was judged too expensive. Since then, around thirty homes on one road, Beach Road, have either gone over the edge or been knocked down before they could.
This brings us to the phrase you'll see in every report on the subject: managed retreat. The idea is that rather than defending every metre of coast for ever, we accept that the shoreline will move, and we plan for it. We help people and roads and services move inland in an orderly way instead of waiting for the next collapse. For Happisburgh, the long-term plan is essentially not to build new defences at all.
Why not just build a wall? Partly it's money. Engineers working on this coast have estimated that a proper rock defence would cost something like ten thousand pounds per metre, before you add the cost of looking after it. Protect a kilometre and a half of cliff and you're already looking at fifteen million pounds, for a village of fewer than a thousand people. And there's a less obvious problem. These cliffs feed sediment into the sea, and that sand travels along the coast and builds up the beaches further south. Lock the cliffs behind concrete, and you may simply move the erosion to someone else's village.
Now, that's the engineers' case, and it's a powerful one. But stand on Beach Road and talk to residents, and you hear something very different. One woman I interviewed had lived there for twenty-two years. In England, homeowners generally receive no compensation when their house is lost to the sea, and you can't insure against it. So the home she'd spent her life paying for was worth almost nothing on paper. A government-funded pilot scheme around 2010 did help some families relocate, but the money ran out long before the problem did. To her, managed retreat didn't sound managed at all. It sounded like being abandoned.
Conservationists add a third perspective. Erosion can be extraordinary for science. In 2013, retreating cliffs at Happisburgh exposed a set of human footprints in the mud that were around eight hundred and fifty thousand years old, the oldest ever found outside Africa. Within a few weeks the tide had washed them away. The cliffs also provide nesting sites for sand martins, small birds that dig their burrows into the soft face. Some conservationists argue that a living coastline, one that's allowed to move, is richer than a fixed one.
And there are engineers who think we've been too pessimistic. Just up the coast at Bacton, in 2019, nearly two million cubic metres of sand were pumped onto the beach to protect a gas terminal and two villages. It's too early to say how long it'll last, but it shows there may be options between building a wall and doing nothing.
So who's right? I'd suggest that each group is answering a slightly different question. The engineers ask what's affordable and what works. The residents ask what's fair. The conservationists ask what's worth keeping. For next Tuesday's seminar, I'd like you to read the shoreline management plan for this stretch of coast and write me fifteen hundred words on which of those questions you think should come first, and why.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| managed retreat/ˌmænɪdʒd rɪˈtriːt/ | a planned decision to let the sea move inland and help people and buildings move away |
| sediment/ˈsedɪmənt/ | sand, mud and small stones carried by water and left somewhere else |
| erosion/ɪˈrəʊʒn/ | the slow wearing away of land by water, wind or ice |
| compensation/ˌkɒmpenˈseɪʃn/ | money paid to someone because they have lost something |
| relocate/ˌriːləʊˈkeɪt/ | move to live or work in a new place |
| exposed/ɪkˈspəʊzd/ | uncovered something so that it could be seen |
| nesting/ˈnestɪŋ/ | making a home where birds lay eggs and raise their young |
| pessimistic/ˌpesɪˈmɪstɪk/ | expecting bad things to happen |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.