C2 British · Text 2
The Afterlife of a Donated Jumper
A researcher in Cardiff follows the clothes people give to charity shops and finds out where most of them really end up.
39 sentences · Tap a sentence to hear it again
Text
Hello, and welcome to this week's episode. I'm Gareth Lloyd, and for the last eighteen months I've been doing something my friends find slightly obsessive. I've been following second-hand clothes. Not people wearing them, I hasten to add, but the clothes themselves, from the moment someone drops a bag off at a charity shop in Cardiff to wherever they finally end up. And I'll start with a confession: before this project, I genuinely believed that when I gave away a jumper, someone in Cardiff would buy it the following week and wear it to the football on Saturday. That's the story we all tell ourselves. It turns out to be true for surprisingly few of the things we donate.
Let me explain the journey. A bag arrives at the back door of a shop, say in Canton or Roath. Volunteers open it, and they have to be fairly ruthless. A shop has a limited amount of rail space, and it has to sell things quickly to stay open, so anything stained, torn, out of season or simply unlikely to sell is put aside within minutes. On average, across the eleven shops I worked with, only around one item in five was actually sold in the shop. One in five. The other four disappear quietly out of the back door, and that's where most of us stop thinking about them.
Those items are collected by textile merchants and taken to large sorting warehouses. There, workers grade everything by hand, often at astonishing speed. I watched one woman sort a whole cage of clothes in under twenty minutes, deciding in a second or two whether a shirt was good enough for one market or another. The better pieces are pressed by a machine into tightly packed bales, each weighing about forty-five kilos, wrapped in plastic and sold abroad, mainly to traders in Eastern Europe and West Africa. The lowest grade, the things nobody will ever wear again, goes to a recycling plant in Leicester, where it's shredded into fibres and turned into things like insulation and mattress filling.
Now, I don't want to sound cynical about any of this. Charity shops raise a great deal of money for good causes, they give volunteers company and purpose, and reusing a garment, anywhere in the world, is far better than burying it in the ground. The bales also support thousands of small businesses abroad. But there are hidden costs, and they've grown enormously in the last twenty years, largely because of fast fashion. We buy far more clothes than our parents did, we wear them fewer times, and many of them are made of cheap mixed fibres that are almost impossible to recycle properly. A trader I spoke to who buys bales for a market in Accra, in Ghana, told me that these days she reckons on roughly a third of each bale being unsellable. She pays for the whole bale, though, and the rubbish becomes her problem, and her city's.
So what should we actually do? I'm wary of anyone who offers a neat solution, but my research points to a few modest changes. Donate less, but better: clean, mended and in season. If something is genuinely worn out, take it to a textile recycling bank rather than hoping a shop will deal with it. And, frankly, the most effective thing any of us can do happens long before the charity shop, at the moment we're tempted to buy a fifth white T-shirt.
I'll end with a small anecdote, because I did try a little experiment of my own. At the start of the project, I wrote a tiny code inside the label of three of my own jumpers and donated them to different shops. Two of them vanished without trace, which rather proves my point. The third, a green woolly thing with a hole in one elbow that I'd darned myself, sold in a shop in Canton four days later for six pounds. The buyer, I discovered at Christmas, was my mum. She thought it looked just like something I'd wear. She was, of course, spot on. Thanks for listening, and I'll see you next week.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| ruthless/ˈruːθləs/ | making hard decisions without letting feelings get in the way |
| bales/beɪlz/ | large blocks of material pressed tightly together and tied up |
| cynical/ˈsɪnɪkl/ | believing that people's good actions are not really what they seem |
| reckons/ˈrekənz/ | expects or calculates, often without being exact |
| modest/ˈmɒdɪst/ | small and not very ambitious |
| tempted/ˈtemptɪd/ | wanting to do something, even though you know it may not be wise |
| anecdote/ˈænɪkdəʊt/ | a short, interesting story about something that really happened |
| spot on/ˌspɒt ˈɒn/ | exactly right |
| hasten to add/ˌheɪsn tʊ ˈæd/ | quickly say something more so that people do not misunderstand |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.