C2 British · Text 4
Opening the Debating Final
A 17-year-old opens a schools' debating final in Edinburgh, arguing that end-of-year exams should be replaced by continuous assessment.
45 sentences · Tap a sentence to hear it again
Text
Madam Chair, members of the judging panel, our worthy opponents, ladies and gentlemen. My name is Callum Reid, and I'm the first speaker for the proposition. I have four minutes, which, my opponents will be relieved to hear, is about three minutes less than I'd like. So I'll be brief, and I'll start with a story. Last May, a friend of mine, a girl who had come top of our year in chemistry for three years running, sat her Higher chemistry exam with a temperature of thirty-nine degrees. She got a C. The certificate she'll show universities and employers says nothing about the three years. It describes two and a half hours on one bad afternoon.
Tonight's motion is that this House would replace exams with continuous assessment. Before we go any further, let me be clear about what we mean, because I suspect the other side would rather we were vague. By exams, we mean high-stakes final exams: a single sitting at the end of a course that decides most or all of the grade. We are not proposing to abolish every test. By continuous assessment, we mean a grade built up over the whole year from a range of marked work: essays, projects, practical tasks and, crucially, short tests done in class under a teacher's supervision. So this is not a debate about tests versus no tests. It's a debate about whether one afternoon should outweigh a year.
Our first argument is about accuracy. An exam measures what a pupil can do on one particular day, under one particular kind of pressure. If we want to know what a young person has genuinely learnt, a snapshot is a poor substitute for the whole album. Continuous assessment gives teachers many chances to see the same skill, which means one illness, one family crisis or one sleepless night no longer skews the result.
Our second argument is about the kind of learning we reward. At the moment, many pupils learn to perform brilliantly for six weeks in spring and to forget nearly everything by the summer holidays. We cram, we pass, we move on. A grade earned across the year rewards the steady, patient work that university and employment actually require.
And our third argument comes from the people this motion affects most: us. This year, our debating society carried out a survey of 1,200 pupils in twelve secondary schools across Edinburgh and the Lothians. Sixty-eight per cent said that exam stress had affected their sleep, and more than half said they had performed worse in an exam than in their classwork during the year. Now, I'll be the first to admit that a survey of pupils about exams is hardly impartial. Nobody has ever met a fifteen-year-old who asked for more exams. But when two thirds of the people being measured say the measuring stick is bent, it's surely worth checking the stick.
Now, I know exactly what the opposition are going to say, because if I were them, I'd say it too. They'll tell you that continuous assessment is unfair and open to cheating. They'll say that coursework done at home can be written by a parent, a tutor or a computer, and that pupils with more help at home will simply do better. That's a serious point, and I want to meet it head on rather than dodge it. Our model puts most of the marks on work done in the classroom, under supervision, exactly like an exam, only spread out. Samples of every school's marking would be checked by external markers, as already happens with some coursework. And I'd gently remind the other side that exams are hardly a level playing field either. A pupil who can afford a private tutor every weekend in the run-up to May has an advantage that no exam hall can remove.
So, to summarise our case. Continuous assessment is more accurate, because it sees a pupil many times rather than once. It rewards the kind of learning that lasts. And, properly supervised, it is no less fair than the system we have now, and arguably fairer. My friend, by the way, is now studying chemistry at Glasgow. She got in on her teachers' testimony and a great deal of stubbornness. Not every pupil will be so lucky, and tonight we're asking you to make sure they don't need to be. I beg to propose.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| supervision/ˌsuːpəˈvɪʒn/ | the act of watching people to make sure they do something correctly and follow the rules |
| outweigh/ˌaʊtˈweɪ/ | be more important than something else |
| snapshot/ˈsnæpʃɒt/ | a quick picture of a situation at one moment |
| skews/skjuːz/ | changes a result so that it is no longer correct or fair |
| cram/kræm/ | learn a lot very quickly just before an exam |
| impartial/ɪmˈpɑːʃl/ | fair, not supporting one side more than the other |
| dodge/dɒdʒ/ | avoid dealing with something in a clever or dishonest way |
| level playing field/ˌlevl ˈpleɪɪŋ fiːld/ | a situation in which everyone has the same chance |
| testimony/ˈtestɪməni/ | a formal statement saying that something is true |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.