C2 British · Dialogue 24
The Classroom Debate
In a geography lesson, Ruby and Jacob debate a wind farm on the hill near their school, and their teacher makes them answer each other's strongest points.
25 lines · Tap a line to hear it again
Dialogue
Mr Kapoor:Right, Year Ten, settle down. Today's motion is: this town should build the wind farm on Hollin Hill. Ruby is proposing, Jacob is opposing. Two minutes each to open, and then I'll be asking questions. Ruby, off you go.
Ruby:Thanks, sir. The council's plan is for six turbines on Hollin Hill, which would generate enough electricity for about nine thousand homes. That's roughly a third of the town. We keep saying we care about climate change; this is our chance to actually do something about it, right here.
Mr Kapoor:Thank you. Jacob.
Jacob:I'm not against wind power. I'm against putting it on that hill. The nearest turbine would be about seven hundred metres from this classroom and less than half a kilometre from the houses on Mill Lane. People there are worried about the noise, and I think they've got every right to be.
Mr Kapoor:Good, clear openings. Now, Ruby, Jacob's main point is noise. Answer it directly, please, not with a different argument.
Ruby:OK. The council's report says that at five hundred metres a modern turbine is about forty decibels. That's roughly the same as a fridge humming in a kitchen.
Jacob:But a fridge isn't on all night outside your bedroom window. And forty decibels is an average. On some nights, when the wind's in the wrong direction, it'll be louder.
Ruby:That's fair, but the report also says the turbines can be slowed down at night if there are complaints. It's a condition of the planning permission.
Mr Kapoor:Jacob, does that satisfy you?
Jacob:Partly. But can be slowed down isn't the same as will be slowed down. Who decides what counts as a complaint?
Mr Kapoor:A sharp question. Let's move on. Jacob, your second point?
Jacob:Wildlife. Hollin Hill's got skylarks nesting on it, and there's a colony of bats in the old barn. A survey found eleven bat deaths a year at a similar wind farm in Wales.
Mr Kapoor:Ruby, that's arguably his strongest point. Respond to it.
Ruby:Eleven a year is sad, I'm not denying that. But the same survey says the biggest threat to bats round here is losing their habitat, and climate change is one of the main causes of that. Also, the plan includes moving the nearest turbine away from the barn and switching them off on calm summer nights, when bats are most active.
Jacob:That helps, I'll admit. Though it means the turbines produce less, so her nine thousand homes figure goes down.
Mr Kapoor:Interesting. Ruby?
Ruby:Slightly, yes. Maybe to eight and a half thousand. It's still a huge amount.
Mr Kapoor:Last area: money. Jacob, you mentioned bills in your notes.
Jacob:Yes. Everyone says wind power makes bills cheaper, but the electricity goes into the national grid, so people in this town won't actually notice any difference.
Ruby:Actually, that's where you're wrong. The company has promised a community fund: a hundred and fifty pounds a year off the bill for every household within three miles. That includes most of Mill Lane.
Jacob:For how long, though? Promises like that have a habit of quietly disappearing.
Ruby:For twenty-five years. It's written into the agreement.
Mr Kapoor:Right, we're out of time. You've both done what I asked: you listened, and you answered the hard points instead of avoiding them. For homework, write one paragraph arguing the side you didn't argue today.
Jacob:Sir, does that mean I've got to argue for it?
Mr Kapoor:Exactly, Jacob. And Ruby, you'll be arguing against. See you on Thursday.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| motion/ˈməʊʃn/ | the idea that people argue for or against in a formal debate |
| proposing/prəˈpəʊzɪŋ/ | speaking for the idea in a debate |
| opposing/əˈpəʊzɪŋ/ | speaking against the idea in a debate |
| turbines/ˈtɜːbaɪnz/ | tall machines with blades that the wind turns to make electricity |
| decibels/ˈdesɪbelz/ | units for measuring how loud a sound is |
| planning permission/ˈplænɪŋ pəˌmɪʃn/ | official permission from the council to build something |
| colony/ˈkɒləni/ | a group of animals of one kind that live together |
| habitat/ˈhæbɪtæt/ | the natural home of an animal or plant |
| national grid/ˌnæʃnəl ˈɡrɪd/ | the network of cables that carries electricity across the whole country |
| have a habit of/ˌhæv ə ˈhæbɪt əv/ | often do something, usually something annoying |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.