C2 British · Dialogue 3
The Admissions Interview
A sixth-former applying to study philosophy at Oxford is given a famous puzzle about a ship and changes his mind more than once.
25 lines · Tap a line to hear it again
Dialogue
Dr Catherine Lowe:Do sit down, Liam. There's no trick to this, I promise. I'm going to give you a puzzle, and I'm far more interested in how you think than in whether you reach the right answer, if there is one.
Liam:OK. That's slightly reassuring. Slightly.
Dr Catherine Lowe:Imagine a wooden ship in a harbour. Over the years, every plank rots and is replaced, one at a time, until after forty years not a single original piece remains. Is it still the same ship?
Liam:I'd say yes. It's kept the same name and the same crew, and it's been in use the whole time. Nobody ever stopped and said, right, that's a different ship now. The change was gradual.
Dr Catherine Lowe:So identity comes from continuity, rather than from the material.
Liam:Yes, I think so. It's a bit like people. Most of the cells in my body have been replaced since I was born, but I'm still me.
Dr Catherine Lowe:Good. Now let me complicate things. Suppose a shipbuilder has been quietly collecting every old plank as it was removed. At the end of the forty years, he puts them all back together in exactly the original order. Now there are two ships. Which one is the ship that first set sail?
Liam:Oh. That's, hmm. Well, the rebuilt one has every original plank, so, actually, I think I want to change my answer.
Dr Catherine Lowe:You're allowed to. Go on.
Liam:If the rebuilt ship is made of all the original material, in the original shape, then it's got a stronger claim. The one in the harbour is more like a very good replica that happens to have kept the name.
Dr Catherine Lowe:But a minute ago you told me identity came from continuity. The ship in the harbour never stopped existing. The rebuilt one spent forty years as a pile of wood in a shed. Doesn't that matter?
Liam:It does, which is annoying. I suppose I've got two criteria pulling in opposite directions. Continuity says the harbour ship, and the material says the rebuilt one.
Dr Catherine Lowe:Let me push you a little further, then. Go back to your example about the body. If a scientist kept every cell you'd ever lost and put them together into a second Liam, would that be you?
Liam:Definitely not. That would be deeply unsettling, for a start. And it wouldn't have my memories. Or would it? I'm honestly not sure.
Dr Catherine Lowe:So for people, you seem to prefer continuity again.
Liam:Yes. So either I'm being inconsistent, or ships and people are genuinely different. A person has a mind that carries on. A ship's just material arranged in a certain way. So maybe, for objects, the question of whether it's the same doesn't have one answer. It depends on why we're asking.
Dr Catherine Lowe:Why we're asking. Explain that.
Liam:Well, if it's about who owns the ship, it's surely the one in the harbour, because the owner paid for all the repairs. But if a museum wanted the ship that sailed to Iceland in 1850, they'd want the original planks. So the word same might mean different things in different situations.
Dr Catherine Lowe:That's a perfectly respectable position, and serious philosophers have defended it. Did you know you'd end up there when you started?
Liam:Honestly, no. I thought I'd answered it in the first ten seconds.
Dr Catherine Lowe:Most people do. The candidates who interest me are the ones who are prepared to abandon a comfortable answer when the argument turns against them. Changing your mind for a good reason isn't a weakness in philosophy. It's rather the point.
Liam:That's good to hear, because I've changed mine about three times in the last ten minutes.
Dr Catherine Lowe:Four, by my count, but who's keeping score? Now, you mentioned in your personal statement that you'd read quite a lot of Descartes.
Liam:Ah. Yes. I may have slightly overstated that.
Dr Catherine Lowe:Well, let's find out, shall we?
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| reassuring/ˌriːəˈʃʊərɪŋ/ | making you feel less worried |
| plank/plæŋk/ | a long, flat piece of wood |
| continuity/ˌkɒntɪˈnjuːəti/ | the fact of carrying on without a break over time |
| replica/ˈreplɪkə/ | an exact copy of something |
| criteria/kraɪˈtɪəriə/ | the standards you use to judge or decide something |
| unsettling/ʌnˈsetlɪŋ/ | making you feel uncomfortable and slightly worried |
| inconsistent/ˌɪnkənˈsɪstənt/ | not following the same rule or idea each time |
| abandon/əˈbændən/ | to give something up completely |
| overstated/ˌəʊvəˈsteɪtɪd/ | said that something was bigger or more important than it really is |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.