Eenglish-tests.com

C1 British · Dialogue 10

We Saw a Different Film

Noah and his aunt disagree about the science fiction film they have just seen, and end up talking about what makes a fair review.

23 lines · Tap a line to hear it again

Dialogue

A

Aunt Meera:Right, a hot chocolate for you and a peppermint tea for me. So, go on then. What did you think?

N

Noah:Honestly? Best film I've seen all year. That scene where the ship flies through the storm on Jupiter… I actually forgot to breathe.

A

Aunt Meera:The effects were stunning, I'll give you that. But I'm afraid I spent most of the second half looking at my watch.

N

Noah:What? How could you be bored? Something was exploding every five minutes!

A

Aunt Meera:That was rather the problem. Two hours and forty minutes is a long time, Noah. They could easily have cut half an hour, and nobody would have missed it.

N

Noah:I wouldn't cut anything. Well, maybe the bit on the ice planet. That was a bit slow.

A

Aunt Meera:And what about the plot? Didn't anything bother you? The captain spends the whole first hour saying the engines can't be repaired, and then she fixes them in about thirty seconds with a screwdriver.

N

Noah:OK, that was a bit convenient. But it's science fiction. You're not supposed to take it that seriously.

A

Aunt Meera:I don't need it to be realistic. Aliens are fine. Faster-than-light travel's fine. I just need the story to follow its own rules. Otherwise nothing feels at stake.

N

Noah:Hmm. I suppose when Kai turned up at the end, alive and well, I did think, hang on, didn't we see him fall into a black hole?

A

Aunt Meera:Exactly! It's a plot hole big enough to fly the spaceship through.

N

Noah:Ha. Fine. But you can't say the whole film was bad because of a few holes. The music was brilliant, the effects were amazing, and the acting was good too.

A

Aunt Meera:I didn't say it was bad. I'd probably give it three stars out of five. You'd give it, what, five?

N

Noah:Four and a half. I'm taking off half a star for the ice planet.

A

Aunt Meera:Very generous. But here's what interests me. We sat next to each other, watched exactly the same thing, and came out with completely different opinions. So which of us is right?

N

Noah:Me, obviously.

A

Aunt Meera:Naturally. But seriously, if you were writing a review for your school website, what would make it fair?

N

Noah:I guess saying what kind of film it is first. Like, if you love action and special effects, you'll love this. If you want a clever story, maybe not.

A

Aunt Meera:That's a really good point. A fair review tells readers who the film is for, rather than pretending there's only one right answer. What else?

N

Noah:Backing up what you say with examples, not just going, it was boring. Like you did with the engines.

A

Aunt Meera:And admitting what works, even when you didn't enjoy it. I'll happily say the storm scene was breathtaking.

N

Noah:And I'll admit the ending didn't make sense. So do I get a second hot chocolate for being so open-minded?

A

Aunt Meera:Nice try. Maybe a biscuit.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
stunning/ˈstʌnɪŋ/extremely beautiful or impressive
I'll give you that/aɪl ˈɡɪv juː ðæt/I agree with you about this point, even if I disagree about other things
plot/plɒt/the story of a film or book: what happens in it
convenient/kənˈviːniənt/here: too easy and lucky to be believable
at stake/ət ˈsteɪk/at risk; something could really be lost or won
plot hole/ˈplɒt həʊl/a mistake in a story where events do not make sense
Backing up/ˌbækɪŋ ˈʌp/giving facts or examples to show that something is true
breathtaking/ˈbreθteɪkɪŋ/so exciting or beautiful that it surprises you
open-minded/ˌəʊpən ˈmaɪndɪd/happy to listen to other people's ideas and change your view

Tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.