C1 British · Dialogue 13
Questions from the Judge
At a regional science fair, a judge asks fifteen-year-old Aisha some tough questions about her research on plastic in the River Thames.
21 lines · Tap a line to hear it again
Dialogue
Professor Wright:Good afternoon. Aisha, is it? I'm Professor Wright. I've read your poster, but I'd like to hear it from you. Two minutes, in your own words.
Aisha:Thank you. So, my project looks at microplastics in the River Thames, from Oxford down to Greenwich. I collected water at five sites in October, filtered it, and counted the tiny bits of plastic under a microscope. The main finding is that the number of pieces went up as the river went through London. At Oxford I found about twelve pieces per litre, and at Greenwich it was nearly fifty.
Professor Wright:That's a clear summary. Let's start with the obvious question. Why only five sites? It's a long river.
Aisha:Partly time, honestly. Each sample took about three hours to filter and count, and I was doing it at weekends. But I also chose the sites on purpose: one upstream of any big town, one after Reading, and three in London, so I could see whether the city made a difference.
Professor Wright:That's reasonable. Now, microplastics are everywhere, including in the air of your lab and on your clothes. How did you make sure you weren't counting fibres from your own jumper?
Aisha:That was the part I worried about most. I wore a cotton lab coat, I only used glass bottles, never plastic, and I rinsed everything three times with filtered water. I also ran what's called a blank: a bottle of clean water that went through exactly the same process.
Professor Wright:And what did your blank show?
Aisha:That's the slightly embarrassing bit. It had four pieces in it.
Professor Wright:Four. So what does that tell you?
Aisha:That some contamination came from somewhere in my process, probably from the air while the filters were drying. I took four away from every result, so Oxford went from sixteen to twelve. But I only ran one blank, so I can't be sure four is the right number.
Professor Wright:I'm glad you've mentioned it rather than hoping I wouldn't ask. Plenty of students here haven't run a blank at all. If you could do the project again, what would you change?
Aisha:Three things. I'd run a blank with every sample, not just one. I'd cover the filters with foil while they dried. And I'd go back to the same sites in a different season, because there was heavy rain that October, and I think that might have washed more plastic into the river.
Professor Wright:Interesting. Why would rain make a difference?
Aisha:Because rain carries things off roads and down drains. A lot of microplastic comes from car tyres wearing down. So a dry month might give quite different numbers.
Professor Wright:That's a genuinely good hypothesis. Did you test it at all?
Aisha:Not properly. I've got one extra sample from Greenwich in August, when it hadn't rained for two weeks, and it had about half as many pieces. But one sample isn't evidence. It's just a hint.
Professor Wright:You'd make a good scientist with that attitude. Last question. Who have you shared your results with?
Aisha:I emailed them to a local river charity. They replied and asked if I'd help with their volunteer sampling next spring.
Professor Wright:Well, that's more real-world use than most projects get. Thank you, Aisha. The results will be announced at four o'clock in the main hall.
Aisha:Thank you. I was so nervous about the blank question.
Professor Wright:Don't be. Admitting a weakness and explaining how you'd fix it is exactly what we look for.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| microplastics/ˈmaɪkrəʊˌplæstɪks/ | extremely small pieces of plastic, often too small to see |
| filtered/ˈfɪltəd/ | passed a liquid through something that catches solid bits |
| upstream/ˌʌpˈstriːm/ | further back along a river, towards the place where it starts |
| fibres/ˈfaɪbəz/ | very thin threads, for example from clothes |
| contamination/kənˌtæmɪˈneɪʃən/ | when something unwanted gets into a sample and makes it less pure |
| foil/fɔɪl/ | very thin metal sheet used for covering food |
| tyres/ˈtaɪəz/ | the rubber rings around the wheels of a car or bike |
| hypothesis/haɪˈpɒθəsɪs/ | an idea that might explain something and that you can test |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.