Eenglish-tests.com

C1 British · Dialogue 20

Help in the Library

Kai is stuck on a history essay about child labour, so a librarian shows him how to find and judge good sources.

21 lines · Tap a line to hear it again

Dialogue

K

Kai:Excuse me, sorry to bother you. I've got a history essay due on Friday, and I'm completely stuck.

L

Librarian:That's what I'm here for. What's the topic?

K

Kai:Child labour in the Industrial Revolution. The question is: how far did conditions for working children improve between 1800 and 1850? I've found loads online, but the websites all say different things. One says children worked twenty hours a day.

L

Librarian:Let's have a look. Hmm. Who wrote this page?

K

Kai:It doesn't say. There are just loads of adverts down the side.

L

Librarian:That's the first warning sign. When I'm deciding whether a website is reliable, I ask four questions. Who wrote it, and are they an expert? When was it written or updated? Does it tell you where its information comes from? And why does the page exist: to inform you, or to sell you something?

K

Kai:So this one fails on pretty much all four.

L

Librarian:I'm afraid so. Compare it with this one, from a university history department. It names the author, it was updated last year, and every claim has a footnote. A twenty-hour shift did happen in a few mills when there was a rush order, but it wasn't typical, and the first site gives no evidence at all.

K

Kai:OK, that makes sense. My teacher keeps going on about primary sources, too, but I'm not sure where to find them.

L

Librarian:A primary source is something produced at the time, by people who were there. And you're in luck. In 1833 Parliament passed a law called the Factory Act, and before that, a committee interviewed children who worked in textile mills. Their answers were printed in a report, and we've got a facsimile of it in our local history room.

K

Kai:You mean I can read what the children actually said?

L

Librarian:Word for word. Here's one. A girl of ten describes starting work at six in the morning and finishing at half past seven in the evening, with forty minutes for lunch. If she arrived late, she lost part of her wages.

K

Kai:That's thirteen and a half hours. And she was ten. That's younger than my sister.

L

Librarian:It's powerful, isn't it? But remember that even primary sources can be biased. Some of the people who gave evidence wanted to shock Parliament into changing the law, so always ask who's speaking and why.

K

Kai:So I shouldn't just believe that either?

L

Librarian:Use it, but question it. That's what makes a good historian. And when you quote it, you'll need to reference it properly, or it could count as plagiarism. Which style does your school use?

K

Kai:I think my teacher said Harvard.

L

Librarian:Then in the essay you put the author and the year straight after the quotation, and at the end, a full list with the title, the year and where each source was published. I'll write the details of this report on a card for you.

K

Kai:Thanks so much. Can I borrow it?

L

Librarian:I'm afraid that one's reference only, so it can't leave the building. But you're welcome to photograph the pages you need, and the history room's open until eight tonight.

K

Kai:Perfect. Then I'm starting right now. Friday suddenly feels a lot less scary.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
reliable/rɪˈlaɪəbl/that you can trust to be true or correct
footnote/ˈfʊtnəʊt/a note at the bottom of a page that says where information comes from
shift/ʃɪft/a period of time when a group of people work
primary sources/ˌpraɪməri ˈsɔːsɪz/documents or objects made at the time by people who were there
facsimile/fækˈsɪməli/an exact copy of an old document or book
biased/ˈbaɪəst/showing one side unfairly, not giving a balanced view
reference/ˈrefrəns/say exactly where information you use comes from
plagiarism/ˈpleɪdʒərɪzəm/using someone else's words or ideas as if they were your own

Tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.