C2 American · Text 6
Farming in Detroit
A radio reporter visits a two-acre farm on empty lots in Detroit and asks whether farms like it really help a neighborhood.
46 sentences · Tap a sentence to hear it again
Text
It's just after six on a Saturday morning on Detroit's east side, and apart from a few birds, the only sound on this block is the hiss of a garden hose. I'm Andrea Wallace, and I'm standing at the edge of what used to be eleven house lots. Today it's Marigold Lane Farm: two acres of tomatoes, collard greens, peppers and beans, planted in rows so straight you'd think someone had measured them with a ruler. As it turns out, someone did.
That someone is Curtis Hale, a retired autoworker who spent thirty-one years on an assembly line before, as he puts it, "trading engines for eggplants." Back in 2014, he bought the first lot from the city for a hundred dollars. It was knee-deep in weeds, and people kept dumping old tires on it. "I just wanted to stop looking at it," he told me. "I wasn't planning to feed anybody." Ten years on, he and a crew of volunteers farm the whole block.
And they do feed people. Last year the farm grew about six thousand pounds of vegetables. Roughly a third went straight to a food pantry two streets away, and the rest was sold at a Saturday stand where prices work on a sliding scale: neighbors pay what they can, and visitors from the suburbs are gently encouraged to pay a little more. In a part of the city where the nearest full-size grocery store is a twenty-minute bus ride away, that matters.
The part of the project Curtis is proudest of, though, isn't the vegetables. Every summer, twelve local teenagers join a paid training program. They work twenty hours a week for eight weeks, at fourteen dollars an hour, and they learn far more than how to pull weeds. They test the soil, keep the farm's accounts, and run the stand themselves. Jasmine, who's sixteen, was weighing bags of green beans when I arrived. "My mom bet me I'd quit in a week," she said, grinning. "That was two summers ago. Now I'm the one who does the spreadsheets."
So far, it sounds like a feel-good story, and in many ways it is. But not everyone thinks farms like this are the answer, and the doubts are worth hearing. Lena Ortiz, a housing researcher who has studied Detroit's vacant land for over a decade, put it bluntly. "A beautiful farm photographs well," she said. "But it doesn't bring back the jobs, the schools or the stores that left. There's a risk that cities point to projects like this and say, look, the neighborhood's fine, when the deeper problems haven't been touched."
She also raised a practical concern: who actually owns the land? Many urban farmers lease their lots rather than buy them, and when property values start to rise, owners can sell to developers, sometimes with only a few months' notice. A farm that took a decade to build can disappear in a single season. Then there's the soil itself. Some of these lots once held houses painted with lead paint, so most farms, including this one, grow everything in raised beds filled with clean soil brought in by truck. It's safe, but it's expensive.
Curtis doesn't dispute any of this. When I put Lena's argument to him, he was quiet for a moment, then nodded. "She's not wrong," he said. "A farm isn't a factory. It's not going to replace what this city lost. But I'd rather have kids out here learning to run a business than staring at another empty lot. You start with what you've got." He's also trying to buy the remaining four lots outright, so that nobody can sell the land out from under them.
Perhaps the honest answer is that both of them are right. Urban farms won't solve the problems that hollowed out neighborhoods like this one, and nobody should pretend they will. But on a quiet Saturday morning, with Jasmine counting change at the stand and a line of neighbors forming before seven, it's hard to call two acres of green a distraction. For Detroit Public Radio, I'm Andrea Wallace.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| dumping/ˈdʌmpɪŋ/ | leaving unwanted things somewhere they should not be |
| sliding scale/ˈslaɪdɪŋ skeɪl/ | a way of setting prices so that people with less money pay less |
| spreadsheets/ˈspredʃiːts/ | computer tables of numbers used to keep records and do sums |
| lease/liːs/ | pay to use land or a building for a fixed time without owning it |
| dispute/dɪˈspjuːt/ | say that something is not true or not right |
| hollowed out/ˈhɑːloʊd aʊt/ | made weak and empty by taking away what was important inside |
| distraction/dɪˈstrækʃən/ | something that takes attention away from what really matters |
| bluntly/ˈblʌntli/ | in a very direct way, without trying to be polite |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.