C2 American · Dialogue 25
The Science Fair Judge
At a state science fair, a judge puts hard questions to a sixteen-year-old about his solar panel project, and his honest answers surprise her.
28 lines · Tap a line to hear it again
Dialogue
Dr. Angela Price:Good afternoon. I'm Dr. Price, one of your judges. You've got about ten minutes, so walk me through it.
Aaron:Hi, thank you. I'm Aaron Reyes, from Pecos, out in West Texas. My project asks how much desert dust reduces the output of solar panels, and whether cleaning them is actually worth it.
Dr. Angela Price:Pecos. So you've seen a few dust storms.
Aaron:More than a few. My grandpa put solar panels on his roof three years ago, and he swore they made less power every spring. Everybody told him he was imagining it, so I decided to find out.
Dr. Angela Price:Good motivation. What did you do?
Aaron:I set up four small panels on his roof, all the same model. Two I cleaned every morning at six with a soft brush, and two I never touched. A data logger recorded the output of each one every fifteen minutes for ten weeks, from March to May.
Dr. Angela Price:And your headline number is eighteen percent.
Aaron:That's the peak. After a big dust storm in week seven, the dirty panels produced eighteen percent less than the clean ones. Across the whole ten weeks the average loss was about eleven percent.
Dr. Angela Price:Eleven is still a lot. Okay, here's where I'm going to push you a little. You have four panels. Isn't that a very small sample to build a conclusion on?
Aaron:Yes, it is. I could only afford four. They were thirty-five dollars each, and my budget was two hundred dollars, including the logger.
Dr. Angela Price:I'm not criticizing your budget. I'm asking what it does to your claim.
Aaron:It means I can't say eighteen percent is true for every panel in Pecos. If one of my dirty panels was just a slightly worse panel, that alone could explain part of the difference. What I can say is that the gap grew after every dust event and shrank after it rained, which is what you'd expect if dust is the cause.
Dr. Angela Price:Reasonable. Next question. Solar panels lose efficiency when they get hot. How did you control for temperature?
Aaron:Honestly? Not well enough. That's the biggest weakness in the whole project.
Dr. Angela Price:Go on.
Aaron:The two dirty panels were on the west end of the roof, because that's where I had space. In the afternoon they got sun a little longer, so they may have been hotter. And I didn't have temperature sensors on the panels themselves, only one air thermometer for all four. So part of my eleven percent could be heat, not dust.
Dr. Angela Price:You're aware that most students at this fair would have tried to hide that.
Aaron:I thought about it, I'll be honest. But my teacher said a judge would find it in about thirty seconds.
Dr. Angela Price:Your teacher is right. So how would you fix it?
Aaron:Three things. First, more panels, at least twelve, and I'd choose which ones get cleaned at random, not by where they sit. Second, a temperature sensor on the back of every panel, so I could adjust the numbers for heat. Third, halfway through I'd swap the groups, so the clean panels become the dirty ones. If the gap follows the dust and not the panel, that's a much stronger result.
Dr. Angela Price:A crossover design. Did someone suggest that to you?
Aaron:No, I read about it in a paper on testing medicines, and I thought, why not panels?
Dr. Angela Price:One last thing. Water is scarce in Pecos. Is cleaning even practical?
Aaron:That's why I used a dry brush, no water at all. It takes my grandpa about four minutes for his whole roof. If the loss is even half of what I found, that's worth it.
Dr. Angela Price:Aaron, I've judged this fair for twelve years. I see plenty of perfect graphs that don't hold up to two questions. Yours has weaknesses, and you found them before I did.
Aaron:Thanks. I'm not sure if that's good or bad.
Dr. Angela Price:It's good. Make sure you're standing by your board at three o'clock. The special awards committee will be coming around, and I'd like them to hear that answer about temperature.
Aaron:Really? Okay. I'll text my grandpa.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| data logger/ˈdeɪtə ˌlɑːɡər/ | a small electronic device that records measurements automatically |
| sample/ˈsæmpəl/ | the small group of things you test to learn about a bigger group |
| claim/kleɪm/ | a statement that something is true, which others may question |
| control for/kənˈtroʊl fɔːr/ | to stop another factor from changing the results of a test |
| adjust/əˈdʒʌst/ | to change something slightly to make it correct |
| crossover/ˈkrɔːsoʊvər/ | a test plan where two groups change places halfway through |
| hold up/ˌhoʊld ˈʌp/ | to stay strong or true when tested |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.