C2 American · Dialogue 17
A Painting to Sell?
Two museum curators in Philadelphia argue about selling a valuable painting to save the rest of the collection.
23 lines · Tap a line to hear it again
Dialogue
James Whitaker:Helen, have you seen the conservation report? The textile collection is in worse shape than we thought. Some of those quilts won't survive another ten years in the conditions they're in.
Dr. Helen Brooks:I read it last night. It's grim. But I have a feeling I know where this is going, James, and I'm not sure I like it.
James Whitaker:Then let me just say it. Morning on the Schuylkill has been sitting in storage for thirty years. Nobody's seen it since 1996, and the last appraisal put it at around twelve million dollars.
Dr. Helen Brooks:And you want to sell it.
James Whitaker:I want to talk about selling it. Clearing the whole conservation backlog would cost about four million. We could fix the climate control in storage, hire two conservators and still put money into the endowment.
Dr. Helen Brooks:The problem is, it isn't just an object on a shelf. The Hale family gave it to the museum in 1952, and the letter that came with it said it was a gift to the people of Philadelphia. If we sell it, what message does that send to the next family thinking about donating something?
James Whitaker:That we look after what we're given? Because right now, frankly, we don't. Keeping a painting in a dark room isn't the same as caring for it.
Dr. Helen Brooks:Fair point. But you know how these sales play out in the press. Museum sells off city's treasure. People stop believing that a gift to a museum is a gift forever, and that trust is what everything we do is built on.
James Whitaker:I'm not saying it's painless. But the professional guidelines are on my side here. A sale is allowed as long as the money goes to new acquisitions or the direct care of the collection. This is textbook direct care.
Dr. Helen Brooks:Allowed isn't the same as wise. And there's another risk. If a private collector buys it, it could disappear into someone's living room in Switzerland, and the public would lose it for good.
James Whitaker:Whereas now the public has it... in a crate in our basement.
Dr. Helen Brooks:Touché. All right, let me ask you something. Why has it been in storage for thirty years? It's not because it's a bad painting.
James Whitaker:No, it's a beautiful painting. It's because it's enormous, almost twelve feet wide, and when the American galleries were rehung in the nineties, they were built around a different story. It just didn't fit anywhere.
Dr. Helen Brooks:So what if we stopped treating it as a problem and started treating it as an asset? I had a call last month with a museum in Houston. They're planning a big exhibition on American rivers, and they asked, very politely, whether we'd ever consider lending the Hale.
James Whitaker:A loan? For how long?
Dr. Helen Brooks:Eighteen months, possibly two years. For a major work, we could ask for a loan fee. Not twelve million, obviously, but maybe two hundred and fifty thousand. And they'd pay to clean and repair the painting before it travels.
James Whitaker:That's not nothing. It doesn't solve the backlog, though.
Dr. Helen Brooks:No, but it buys us time. And here's the second half of my idea. When the painting comes home, we hang it in the main hall and build a fundraising campaign around it. Save Philadelphia's quilts, with the Hale as the face of it. People give money to things they can actually see.
James Whitaker:I'll admit, that's smarter than a sale that ends up on the front page. But if the campaign falls flat, I want the option of selling back on the table.
Dr. Helen Brooks:That's fair. I can live with that, as long as it's a last resort and not plan A.
James Whitaker:Deal. So we propose the Houston loan to the board, then the campaign, and a sale only if both fail.
Dr. Helen Brooks:Agreed. And James? Thank you for pushing. Somebody had to ask the uncomfortable question.
James Whitaker:That's what I'm here for. Uncomfortable questions and very cold basements.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| appraisal/əˈpreɪzəl/ | an expert's opinion of how much something is worth |
| backlog/ˈbæklɑːɡ/ | a lot of work that is waiting to be done and should have been done earlier |
| endowment/ɪnˈdaʊmənt/ | a large sum of money kept by an organization to give it income for the future |
| textbook/ˈtekstbʊk/ | a perfect, typical example of something |
| crate/kreɪt/ | a large wooden box for storing or moving things |
| rehung/ˌriːˈhʌŋ/ | with the pictures taken down and put up again in a new order |
| asset/ˈæset/ | something useful or valuable that helps you |
| falls flat/fɔːlz ˈflæt/ | fails to have the effect that people hoped for |
| last resort/ˌlæst rɪˈzɔːrt/ | the thing you do only when every other plan has failed |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.