C2 American · Dialogue 2
The Outlier
Two chemistry students argue about one result that doesn't fit, search their lab notebook for a reason and agree on an honest way to report it.
26 lines · Tap a line to hear it again
Dialogue
Ethan:Okay, I've typed everything into the spreadsheet, and trial five is ruining my life.
Grace:It's a number, Ethan, not a villain. What does it say?
Ethan:Thirty-one point six milliliters. Every other trial is between twenty-three point nine and twenty-four point three. It's a textbook outlier. If we leave it in, it skews the whole average and our vitamin C result looks terrible.
Grace:So what are you suggesting?
Ethan:That we quietly delete it. Five clean trials look much more professional than six messy ones. Professor Okafor will never know.
Grace:That's exactly my problem. If we remove it just because we don't like it, that's not science, that's cherry-picking. We'd be choosing the data that tells the story we want.
Ethan:Come on, Grace, it's one number in a sophomore lab report. Nobody's going to accuse us of fudging our results.
Grace:Maybe not this time. But this is exactly how people get into bad habits. If there's a real reason the trial went wrong, then fine, we can leave it out of the average and explain why. If there isn't, it stays in.
Ethan:And how are we supposed to find a reason three days later?
Grace:The lab notebook. That's what it's for. Pass it over. What time did we start trial five?
Ethan:Uh, according to my handwriting, which I can barely read, about three thirty-five. We'd just come back from the stockroom.
Grace:Right. And look at this, three forty p.m. Someone's scrawled 'refilled burette, bubble?' with a question mark. Is that yours?
Ethan:No, that's definitely yours. I don't do question marks. I'm far too confident.
Grace:Clearly. Anyway, I remember now. We refilled the burette halfway through, and I thought I saw a tiny air bubble trapped near the tip. I meant to tap it out, but then the TA called everyone over for the safety announcement.
Ethan:Wait, would a bubble actually make the reading bigger?
Grace:It would. If the bubble escapes while you're adding the solution, the volume you read is larger than the volume that actually went into the flask. That fits a reading that's seven milliliters too high.
Ethan:So I was right to delete it after all.
Grace:Not so fast. We have a likely reason, not a certain one. I didn't write 'bubble' with a question mark for fun. So here's what I think we do. We keep trial five in the results table, but we mark it as anomalous and add a footnote explaining the possible air bubble at three forty.
Ethan:And the average?
Grace:We calculate it from the five other trials, and we say so clearly. Then in the error analysis we suggest checking the burette tip after every refill. That way anyone reading it can see exactly what we did and decide for themselves.
Ethan:Honestly, that sounds like more work than pressing delete.
Grace:About twenty minutes more. And Professor Okafor gives points for rigor, remember? Last week she said an honest error analysis is worth more than a perfect-looking graph.
Ethan:Fine, you've convinced me. Although part of me still wants to frame trial five and hang it on the wall as a warning.
Grace:Do that after Thursday. The report's due at nine a.m., and I'd like to sleep at some point tonight.
Ethan:You write the footnote, I'll fix the table. And Grace, thanks for not letting me do something dumb.
Grace:Anytime. That's what lab partners are for.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| outlier/ˈaʊtlaɪər/ | a result that is very different from all the others |
| skews/skjuːz/ | changes a result so that it is no longer correct or fair |
| cherry-picking/ˈtʃeri ˌpɪkɪŋ/ | choosing only the facts that support what you want to show |
| fudging/ˈfʌdʒɪŋ/ | changing facts or numbers a little so they look better than they are |
| scrawled/skrɔːld/ | wrote quickly and untidily |
| burette/bjʊˈret/ | a long glass tube with marks and a tap, used to add exact amounts of liquid |
| anomalous/əˈnɑːmələs/ | different from what is normal or expected |
| footnote/ˈfʊtnoʊt/ | a short note at the bottom of a page that explains something |
| rigor/ˈrɪɡər/ | great care and attention to detail |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.