Eenglish-tests.com

C2 American · Dialogue 10

The Damage Claim

Returning a rental car at Phoenix airport, Dr. Priya Shah is told she owes $450 for a scratch, and she has the photos to prove it was already there.

26 lines · Tap a line to hear it again

Dialogue

R

Rental agent:Good afternoon, Dr. Shah. Welcome back. I've got your return here, the white SUV, twelve hundred and six miles. Before I close out the contract, our lot attendant flagged something on the inspection.

D

Dr. Priya Shah:Flagged something? The car was fine. What did he find?

R

Rental agent:There's a scratch on the rear door on the driver's side, about six inches long. Under our damage policy, that's assessed at four hundred and fifty dollars, which would be charged to the card on file.

D

Dr. Priya Shah:Four hundred and fifty dollars. Okay. I'm going to stop you there, because I'm fairly sure that scratch was already there when I picked the car up.

R

Rental agent:I understand. Unfortunately, our checkout record from Monday shows the car left with no damage noted.

D

Dr. Priya Shah:Then the checkout record is wrong. I always photograph a rental before I drive it. It's a habit from a trip to Denver, where I nearly paid for somebody else's dent. Here, this is the rear door on the driver's side. You can see the scratch right there, just above the handle.

R

Rental agent:May I? Okay, yes. That does look like the same mark.

D

Dr. Priya Shah:And if you tap the info button, it shows the time and the place. Monday, six forty-two a.m., the Rental Car Center, level two, space C-14.

R

Rental agent:I see it. And I'm not doubting you, Dr. Shah. The difficulty is that our policy asks customers to report any existing damage at the exit booth before they leave the lot, so it can be added to the record. That's in section seven of the rental agreement.

D

Dr. Priya Shah:With respect, it was six forty in the morning, there was nobody in the exit booth, and the gate opened automatically. Who exactly was I supposed to report it to?

R

Rental agent:That's... a fair point. The booth isn't staffed until seven.

D

Dr. Priya Shah:So the policy asks me to do something that your own setup makes impossible. I'm not trying to be difficult. I just don't think it's reasonable to pay for damage I can prove I didn't cause.

R

Rental agent:I understand your frustration. I am required to follow the process, though. If you'd like to dispute the charge, you can submit your photos on our claims website, and a specialist will review them within ten to fourteen business days.

D

Dr. Priya Shah:Ten to fourteen business days, while four hundred and fifty dollars sits on my credit card? No, I'm sorry. I'd like to speak to a manager, please.

R

Rental agent:Of course. She's on her break, but she'll be back in about fifteen minutes. Actually, let me check one more thing while we wait. I want to see who had the car before you.

D

Dr. Priya Shah:Thank you. Take your time.

R

Rental agent:Okay, this is interesting. The previous renter returned it on Sunday night at eleven fifty, through after-hours drop-off. That means nobody inspected it when it came back. And then it went straight out to you first thing Monday.

D

Dr. Priya Shah:So the car was never actually checked between the two rentals.

R

Rental agent:It doesn't look like it. The "no damage" on your checkout record was probably just copied from the one before. Honestly, that's on us, not you.

D

Dr. Priya Shah:I appreciate you saying that.

R

Rental agent:I'm going to waive the charge. I don't need the manager for that; I can do it at my level. I'll attach your photos to the file and add a note, so nobody bills you for it later by mistake. You'll get an email confirming it within the hour.

D

Dr. Priya Shah:That's a relief. Thank you, really. And I'm sorry if I sounded a little sharp a minute ago.

R

Rental agent:Not at all. You came prepared. Most people don't, and then it's their word against a form. If I can make a suggestion for next time, our app lets you upload photos before you leave the lot. They go straight into the record.

D

Dr. Priya Shah:I'll do that. Although, between us, I'll still take my own.

R

Rental agent:Between us, so would I. Your receipt's printing now. Do you need the shuttle to Terminal 4?

D

Dr. Priya Shah:Yes, please. My flight's at five fifteen, so I've got plenty of time. Now.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
flagged/flæɡd/pointed out a possible problem so that someone checks it
assessed/əˈsest/officially judged to be worth or cost a certain amount
card on file/ˌkɑːrd ɑːn ˈfaɪl/the payment card details a company has kept from when you booked
dent/dent/a small hollow in a hard surface where something has hit it
staffed/stæft/having workers there to do the job
dispute/dɪˈspjuːt/to say officially that something is wrong and should be changed
business days/ˈbɪznəs ˌdeɪz/working days, so not Saturdays, Sundays or holidays
on us/ˈɑːn ʌs/our fault and our responsibility
waive/weɪv/to officially decide not to make someone pay or follow a rule

Tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.