Eenglish-tests.com

C2 American · Dialogue 21

Print or Digital?

A small-town library board in Iowa argues about how to spend a $30,000 gift, until a teenage member puts a third idea on the table.

28 lines · Tap a line to hear it again

Dialogue

L

Library director:Let's get started. Thanks for coming out on a Tuesday night, especially in this snow. The big item tonight is the thirty thousand dollars from the Hendricks bequest. The family asked only that we spend it on something that will still matter in ten years.

M

Mrs. Joan Pruitt:Which, if you ask me, rules out anything that disappears when a license runs out.

L

Library director:I'm not going to pretend that's a silly point, Joan. But let me put the numbers on the table first. Last year our print circulation was about forty-one thousand loans, down six percent. Digital loans were nine and a half thousand, up thirty-eight percent. That's the third year in a row digital has grown by over a third.

Z

Zoe:Is that thirty-eight percent more people, or the same people borrowing more?

L

Library director:Mostly the same people. About four hundred regular users, many of them commuters who listen on the drive to Cedar Rapids.

M

Mrs. Joan Pruitt:Four hundred people, in a town of eight thousand. And the e-books aren't even ours, are they? Tell Zoe what we pay.

L

Library director:A paperback costs us around eighteen dollars, and it's ours until it falls apart. A popular e-book license can cost fifty-five dollars, and it expires after twenty-six loans or two years, whichever comes first. Then we pay again.

Z

Zoe:Wait, seriously? That's kind of outrageous.

M

Mrs. Joan Pruitt:Thank you. That's what I've been saying since 2019. When the internet went down for three days after the ice storm, who was sitting in our reading room? Families with no power at home, reading books by the window.

L

Library director:I remember. I was the one making the coffee. Nobody's suggesting we stop buying print, Joan. My proposal was twenty thousand on digital and ten on print, because the waiting lists are getting ridiculous. Some titles have thirty people in line for one copy.

M

Mrs. Joan Pruitt:Spend twenty thousand dollars on that, and in two years most of it will have evaporated. That's not what the Hendricks family meant by ten years.

Z

Zoe:Can I suggest something different? Honestly, you're both talking about books, and most kids my age come here for something else.

L

Library director:Go ahead. That's why you're on the board.

Z

Zoe:A maker space. A 3D printer is about two thousand four hundred dollars. Sewing machines, some electronics kits. The old periodicals room is empty half the week anyway. The high school robotics club has a waiting list of fifty, because the school can't take any more.

M

Mrs. Joan Pruitt:A 3D printer in a library. My husband would have choked on his coffee.

Z

Zoe:Maybe, but think about it, Mrs. Pruitt. Kids would walk in for the printer and walk past the books on the way. Half of them haven't been inside since story time when they were six.

M

Mrs. Joan Pruitt:Hmm. That's actually a better argument than I was expecting. Would it last ten years, though? Machines break.

Z

Zoe:The printer, maybe not. But the skills would. And so would the room.

L

Library director:I hadn't considered that, and it complicates my nice, tidy proposal. What if we split it three ways? Joan, would you accept twelve thousand on print, focused on what people ask for, like large-print books and local history?

M

Mrs. Joan Pruitt:Large print, yes. Half my friends can't read a normal paperback anymore. And nobody else will ever publish local history digitally. Fine. Twelve.

L

Library director:Then ten on digital, but only on licenses that don't expire, wherever we can get them. They cost more per title, but we keep them.

Z

Zoe:And eight for the maker space?

L

Library director:Eight for a one-year pilot. If nobody uses it, the leftover money goes back into the collection. If it's busy, we look for a grant to keep it going.

M

Mrs. Joan Pruitt:I can live with that. On one condition: Zoe reports back to this board in person, not in some email nobody reads.

Z

Zoe:Deal. I'll even bring numbers. Apparently that's what wins arguments around here.

L

Library director:It does. I'll put the motion in writing: twelve, ten and eight, with a review in twelve months. All in favor?

M

Mrs. Joan Pruitt:Aye.

Z

Zoe:Aye. That was way more fun than I thought it would be.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
bequest/bɪˈkwest/money or property that someone leaves to a person or group after they die
circulation/ˌsɜːrkjəˈleɪʃən/the number of times a library's books are borrowed
expires/ɪkˈspaɪərz/stops being valid after a fixed time
outrageous/aʊtˈreɪdʒəs/very shocking and unfair
evaporated/ɪˈvæpəreɪtɪd/disappeared slowly until nothing was left
periodicals/ˌpɪriˈɑːdɪkəlz/magazines and journals that come out regularly
complicates/ˈkɑːmplɪkeɪts/makes something more difficult to deal with
pilot/ˈpaɪlət/a small test of a new plan before deciding to keep it
motion/ˈmoʊʃən/a formal suggestion that a meeting votes on

Tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.