Eenglish-tests.com

C1 American · Text 6

Why Small Choices Tire Us

On his psychology podcast, Marcus looks at decision fatigue: a famous study about judges, the doubts about it, and three ideas he uses at home.

49 sentences · Tap a sentence to hear it again

Text

Hey, everyone, welcome back to Brain Snacks, the show where we take one big idea from psychology and chew on it for about fifteen minutes. I'm Marcus. Before we start, a quick confession. This morning I stood in front of my closet for, and I'm not kidding, eleven minutes, trying to decide between two gray sweaters that look almost exactly the same. By the time I left the house, I felt like I'd already done a full day's work. And that, as it happens, is exactly what today's episode is about.

The idea is called decision fatigue. The basic claim is that making choices uses up some kind of mental energy, so the more decisions you make in a day, the worse your later decisions get. You just start taking the easy way out. You say yes to whatever's in front of you, or you put the decision off completely.

The most famous evidence comes from a study published in 2011. Researchers looked at more than a thousand decisions made by judges in Israel, who were deciding whether people in prison could be let out early. The results were striking. At the start of the day, and right after the judges took a food break, about 65 percent of requests were approved. But as each session went on, that number fell steadily, almost to zero, until the next break, when it jumped right back up. The message seemed clear: a tired, hungry judge is more likely to say no, because saying no is the safe, easy option. The study was everywhere. I've heard it quoted in business meetings, in parenting books, even by my dentist.

But here's the twist, and it's the reason I wanted to do this episode. Later researchers took a closer look, and they weren't so sure. One group pointed out that the order of the cases wasn't random. People who didn't have a lawyer tended to come at the end of each session, and their requests were less likely to succeed anyway. Another researcher argued that the drop was simply too large to be explained by tiredness alone. If hunger really had that much effect, he said, courts would be chaos. And when scientists tried to repeat some of the classic willpower experiments, many of them couldn't get the same results. So the honest answer is that the famous study is probably exaggerated, and the science of mental energy is still being argued about.

Does that mean decision fatigue is nonsense? I don't think so. Most of us know the feeling of standing in a grocery store at seven in the evening, staring at forty kinds of pasta sauce and wanting to cry. Even if the exact mechanism isn't clear, cutting down on small, pointless choices seems to free up attention for the ones that matter. So here are three things I've actually tried.

First, Sunday planning. Every Sunday evening, I spend about twenty minutes laying out my outfits for the week and writing a meal plan on the fridge. Monday is tacos, Wednesday is soup, and Friday is pizza, always. My kids complained for about two weeks, and now they'd complain much louder if Friday wasn't pizza. Second, defaults. I have the same breakfast every weekday, oatmeal with blueberries, so I never have to think about it. Third, I try to make my most important decisions in the morning, when my head is clearest. If someone emails me a big question at six in the evening, I sleep on it.

Now, a word of caution. This isn't about turning your life into a rigid routine. Some choices are fun, and you shouldn't automate joy. If picking a new recipe is the best part of your week, keep it! The goal is to stop wasting energy on things you don't care about. Which brings me back to those two gray sweaters. Tomorrow, I'm wearing the one on the left. I've already decided. Next week on Brain Snacks: why we're so bad at guessing how long things will take. See you then.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
confession/kənˈfeʃən/telling people something a little embarrassing about yourself
decision fatigue/dɪˈsɪʒən fəˈtiːɡ/the tired feeling that comes from making too many choices
striking/ˈstraɪkɪŋ/very surprising and easy to notice
steadily/ˈstedəli/slowly but all the time, without stopping
exaggerated/ɪɡˈzædʒəreɪtɪd/made to seem bigger or more important than it really is
mechanism/ˈmekənɪzəm/the way something works
defaults/dɪˈfɔːlts/choices that are already made, which you keep unless you change them
sleep on it/sliːp ɑːn ɪt/wait until the next day before you make up your mind
rigid/ˈrɪdʒɪd/very strict and hard to change
automate/ˈɔːtəmeɪt/make something happen by itself, without thought or effort

Tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.