Eenglish-tests.com

C1 American · Text 24

The Gift of Failing

In a conference talk, Dr. Angela Kim tells how she failed her first chemistry exam and argues that schools should reward good attempts, not only right answers.

47 sentences · Tap a sentence to hear it again

Text

I'd like to start with a number: thirty-eight. That's the score I got on my first chemistry exam in college. Not thirty-eight percent of something impressive; thirty-eight out of a hundred, in a class where the average was seventy-one. I was eighteen, I'd been a straight-A student all through high school, and I remember sitting in my car in the parking lot for almost an hour, not even crying, just staring at that number and thinking, well, I guess I'm not a science person after all.

I came very close to switching my major that week. The form was printed out. What stopped me was an email from my professor, Dr. Ruth Feldman, asking everyone who had scored under fifty to come to her office hours. I went, mostly because I was too embarrassed not to. She didn't tell me to work harder. Instead, she gave me back my exam and asked me to explain, out loud, how I'd gotten each wrong answer. About ten minutes in, we both realized the problem. I'd memorized everything and understood almost nothing. In high school, that had been enough. In college, it wasn't.

So I changed the way I studied, and by the end of the semester I had a B. Today I'm a chemistry professor myself, and I tell my students that story on the first day of every course. But I want to be careful here, because there's a version of this story that's too neat, and I think it can actually do harm.

Many of you will have heard of the idea of a growth mindset, from the psychologist Carol Dweck. The basic idea is that people who believe their abilities can grow tend to keep going when things get hard, while people who believe ability is fixed tend to give up. It's a powerful idea, and I believe there's real truth in it. But in the last few years, some very large studies have found that teaching students about growth mindset improves their grades much less than people hoped. The effect is real, but it's small, and it's mostly seen in students who were already struggling.

Dweck herself has warned about something she calls a false growth mindset. That's when adults simply praise effort, saying things like "Great job, you tried so hard," even when the effort isn't working. If I had just tried harder at memorizing in my first semester, I'd have failed again, only more tiredly. Effort on its own isn't the point. What helped me was a new strategy, and someone who took the time to look at my thinking.

Which brings me to my main point. Most of our schools, and most of our colleges, reward one thing: the right answer at the end. If you get the answer, you get the points. If you don't, you get nothing, even if your reasoning was ninety percent correct. We tell students that mistakes are how we learn, and then we penalize every single one of them.

In my own classes, I've tried to change that. Students get points for showing their reasoning clearly, even when the final answer is wrong. After each exam, they can write corrections, explaining exactly where their thinking went off track, and earn back up to half of the points they lost. Some colleagues told me this would make my courses too easy. It hasn't. Grades have gone up a little, but what's changed most is the questions people ask. They come to office hours now with their mistakes, not hiding them.

I'm not saying we should stop caring about right answers. Bridges need to stay up, and medicines need the right dose. But a good attempt that goes wrong in an interesting way often teaches us more than a lucky guess. If we want young people to take intellectual risks, we need to stop making every setback feel like a final verdict.

Thirty-eight. I still have that exam in my desk drawer. It's the most useful thing I ever got from a test. Thank you.

Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.

Glossary

WordMeaning
major/ˈmeɪdʒər/the main subject that a student studies at college
memorized/ˈmeməraɪzd/learned something so well that you can repeat it exactly
mindset/ˈmaɪndset/a person's usual way of thinking about things
strategy/ˈstrætədʒi/a careful plan or method for reaching a goal
penalize/ˈpiːnəlaɪz/punish someone, for example by taking away points
intellectual/ˌɪntəˈlektʃuəl/connected with thinking and using your mind
setback/ˈsetbæk/a problem that stops you from making progress for a while
verdict/ˈvɜːrdɪkt/a final decision or judgment about something

Tests

Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.